Alright, sports card aficionados! 📣 We’re diving deep into the treasure trove of one of the NFL’s greatest quarterbacks, Aaron Rodgers. Whether you’re in it for the love of the game, the thrill of the chase, or the cold hard ROI, we’ve got the lowdown on the Most Valuable Aaron Rodgers Rookie Cards.
📌 The Value Option – Are you a savvy collector looking for a blend of rarity and affordability? Consider the 2005 Ultra Aaron Rodgers RC #202. Limited to 599 copies and with a recent PSA 10 selling at a comfortable $511, this is a steal for both newbies and veterans.
📌 The Mid-Level Marvel – Priced just right, the 2005 SPX Aaron Rodgers RC Patch Auto #223 strikes the balance between investment and prestige. With only 250 ever made and a PSA 10 recently snagging $3,840 at auction, there’s undeniable upward momentum for this gem.
📌 The Blue-Chip Beast – Serious about your collection? Look no further than the 2005 Playoff Contenders Aaron Rodgers RC Auto #101. Touted as the Holy Grail of Rodgers’ cards, this beast recently fetched a whopping $13,200 at auction! With only 37 PSA 10s out there, rarity and prestige make this the crown jewel for high-rollers.
Aaron Rodgers Rookie Card List
Hold onto your seats, because we’re about to get into the nitty-gritty of each card. Price fluctuations, market insights, and expert analysis – it’s all here! Plus, if you’ve got some thoughts to share, I want to hear them! Drop a comment below and let’s get the discussion rolling.
#17. 2005 Topps Turkey Red Aaron Rodgers RC #221
2005 Topps Turkey Red Aaron Rodgers RC Supply
PSA has graded 801 of the Aaron Rodgers Topps Turkey Red rookie cards. Out of these, 504 received a gem mint 10, 244 a mint 9, and the remainder graded 8.5 or below. Given the abundance of PSA 10 examples and the limited popularity of the Topps Turkey Red brand in football cards, the value of base cards remains subdued.
However, it’s worth noting the set includes sought-after parallels such as White, Red, Black, and Gold, as well as autographs that pique collectors’ interest.
2005 Topps Turkey Red Aaron Rodgers RC Market Insights
In March 2023, PWWC auctioned a PSA 10 example for $162, marking a significant decrease from the $384 in March 2022 and even more pronounced from the $660 in February 2021.
This downward trend suggests the cards may have bottomed out in value, making it a potential buying opportunity, especially with an eye towards Rodgers’ performance in the upcoming season.
#16. 2005 Topps Heritage Aaron Rodgers RC #344
2005 Topps Heritage Aaron Rodgers RC Supply
PSA has graded 493 of the 2005 Topps Heritage Aaron Rodgers rookie cards. Of these, 109 have achieved a PSA 10 grade, 67 were graded as mint 9, and the remaining cards were graded PSA 8.5 or lower. This set features a design reminiscent of the 1958 Topps football card set. Additionally, there’s a Short Print (SP) rookie card of Rodgers in the set at #344, which has a value comparable to the regular card.
2005 Topps Heritage Aaron Rodgers RC Value
In September 2023, PWCC Auctions sold a PSA 10 example of this card for $210. Cards graded PSA 9 typically sell for between $55 to $75, whereas PSA 8 cards fetch around $30.
#15. 2005 Leaf Rookies & Stars Aaron Rodgers RC #201
- Serial Numbered: 105/799
- Grade: BGS 9.5
- Auction House: PWCC Auctions
- Sale Date: October 2023
- Sale Price: $312
2005 Leaf R&S Aaron Rodgers RC Value
PWCC sold a BGS 9.5 Aaron Rodgers Leaf R&S rookie card in October 2023 for $312. PSA 9 examples sell between $125 to $175 while a PSA 8 can be picked up for as little as $100.
#14. 2005 Topps Aaron Rodgers RC #431
2005 Topps Aaron Rodgers RC Supply
PSA has graded 9,735 of the 2005 Topps Aaron Rodgers rookie cards. Of these, 3,380 have achieved a PSA 10 grade, 4,011 received a mint 9, and the remainder were graded PSA 8.5 or lower. There’s a significant number of cards with the PSA 10 grade, and their value peaked at $800 in 2021.
2005 Topps Aaron Rodgers RC Value
A PSA 10 example of this card was auctioned by PWCC Auctions in September 2023 and sold for $312. Cards graded PSA 9 typically sell for between $60 to $90, whereas PSA 8 cards are valued around $40.
#13. 2005 Bowman Aaron Rodgers RC #112
2005 Bowman Aaron Rodgers RC Supply
PSA has graded 1,807 of the 2005 Bowman Rodgers rookie cards. Out of these, 184 have been graded as gem mint 10, 735 as mint 9, with the remainder at PSA 8.5 or less. With only 184 attaining PSA 10 status, cards in near-perfect condition are quite rare.
2005 Bowman Aaron Rodgers RC Value
A PSA 10 example was sold by PWCC Auctions in September 2023 for $336. Cards in PSA 9 condition typically range from $55 to $70, while a PSA 8 is valued around $30.
#12. 2005 Leaf Certified Aaron Rodgers RC #162
- Grade: PSA 10
- Auction House: PWCC Auctions
- Sale Date: November 2022
- Sale Price: $396
#11. 2005 Ultra Aaron Rodgers RC #202
- Serial Number: 025/599
- Grade: PSA 10
- Auction House: Goldin Auctions
- Sale Date: September 2023
- Sale Price: $511
2005 Ultra Aaron Rodgers RC Supply
The 2005 Ultra Aaron Rodgers rookie card from the base set has a limited production of only 599 copies, making it inherently rare. PSA has graded a mere 52 of these cards.
Of this number, 19 achieved the gem mint 10 status, 15 were graded as mint 9, and the remaining were graded PSA 8.5 or lower. Given that only 19 of them have reached the PSA 10 grade, cards in near-perfect condition are extremely rare.
2005 Ultra Aaron Rodgers RC Value
In June 2022, a PSA 10 example of this card was auctioned off by Goldin Auctions for $511. Cards graded at PSA 9 typically sell in the range of $250 to $350. Meanwhile, a PSA 8 example was recently purchased on eBay for $58.
Due to the challenges in grading the Ultra set and its limited supply, it might be an opportune moment for collectors to consider acquiring one.
#10. 2005 Finest Aaron Rodgers RC Autograph
- Serial Number: 041/299
- Grade: PSA 9
- Auction House: PWCC Auctions
- Sale Date: September 2023
- Sale Price: $720
2005 Finest Aaron Rodgers RC Auto Supply
PSA has graded 63 of Rodgers’ 2005 Topps Finest RC Autos: 13 at gem mint 10, 33 at mint 9, with the rest lower. Given the limited graded examples, their value appears understated.
2005 Finest Aaron Rodgers RC Auto Market Trends
A PSA 9 recently sold at PWCC for $720, a dip from its $1,290 price in September 2022, but an increase from the $445 in 2019.
#9. 2005 E-Topps Aaron Rodgers RC #57
- Print Run: /1200
- Grade: BGS 10
- Auction House: PWCC Auctions
- Sale Date: May 2023
- Sale Price: $1,050
#8. 2005 Playoff Prestige Aaron Rodgers RC Auto
#7. 2005 Topps Chrome Aaron Rodgers RC #190
2005 Topps Chrome Aaron Rodgers RC Supply
Topps Chrome cards stand out for their chromium finish and rarity. PSA graded 1,428 of Rodgers’ 2005 editions: 256 at gem mint 10, 789 at mint 9, and the rest lower.
2005 Topps Chrome Aaron Rodgers RC Market Dynamics
A PSA 10 recently fetched $1,290 in a July 2023 PWCC auction. PSA 9s range from $300 to $450. For a savvy investment, consider the refractor parallels.
#6. 2005 Bowman Chrome Aaron Rodgers RC Auto #221
#5. 2005 Ultimate Collection Aaron Rodgers RC Auto #242
- Serial Number: 29/99
- Grade: BGS 9.5
- Auction House: Goldin Auctions
- Sale Date: March 2023
- Sale Price: $3,000
2005 Ultimate Collection Aaron Rodgers RC Supply
The Aaron Rodgers 2005 Ultimate Collection rookie card boasts an on-card autograph and is restricted to a mere 99 copies. Owing to their premium nature within the hobby, these cards frequently command top dollar.
Beckett has graded 59 of these cards: 28 achieved the gem mint 9.5 status, 23 were graded as mint 9, and the rest were evaluated at 8.5 or lower.
2005 Ultimate Collection Aaron Rodgers RC Value
In March 2023, Goldin Auctions presented a BGS 9.5 example for auction, which sold for $3,000. This was notably lower than its previous selling price of $8,471 in February 2022. Given the scarcity of these cards and the difficulties in grading them, they remain a robust investment choice for those seeking Aaron Rodgers rookie cards.
#4. 2005 SPX Aaron Rodgers RC Patch Auto #223
- Serial Number: 140/250
- Grade: PSA 10
- Auction House: PWCC Auctions
- Sale Date: September 2023
- Sale Price: $3,840
2005 SPX Aaron Rodgers RC Supply
PSA graded 51 of the 2005 SPX Aaron Rodgers rookie patch autographs with 16 grading gem mint 10, 16 mint 9, and the remaining 8.5 or less.
2005 SPX Aaron Rodgers RC Value
PWCC Auctions sold the PSA 10 example shown above in September 2023 for $3,840. These are down from early 2022 when a PSA 10 sold for $7,200. Stay posted for mint 9 examples to hit the market or rarer parallels.
#3. 2005 Exquisite Collection Aaron Rodgers RC Jersey Auto #106
- Serial Number: 100/199
- Grade: BGS 9.5
- Auction House: PWCC Auctions
- Sale Date: January 2023
- Sale Price: $8,700
2005 Exquisite Collection Aaron Rodgers Holy Grail RPA RC
Beckett has graded 119 of the Aaron Rodgers Exquisite Collection RPAs. Of these, 23 achieved a gem mint 9.5 rating, 47 were mint 9, and the remainder scored 8.5 or less. Due to the card’s thick stock, delicate corners, and edges, it presents grading challenges.
Featuring dual patches, a serial number out of 199, vivid blue ink, and the prestigious branding of the Upper Deck Exquisite Collection, this card is hailed as Aaron Rodgers’ Holy Grail RPA (Rookie Patch Autograph).
2005 Exquisite Collection Aaron Rodgers RC Market Insights
In January 2023, PWCC auctioned a BGS 9.5 example for $8,700. While this represents an increase from the $4,600 in October 2020, it’s a decrease from the March 2022 sale price of $31,200 for a similar BGS 9.5 card.
Given this price volatility, it’s prudent for collectors to monitor BGS and PSA 9 mint condition examples, especially during market lulls, to potentially secure a favorable deal.
#2. 2005 SP Authentic Aaron Rodgers RC Jersey Auto #252
- Serial Number: 24/99
- Grade: BGS 9.5
- Auction House: PWCC Auctions
- Sale Date: September 2023
- Sale Price: $9,600
2005 SP Authentic Aaron Rodgers RC Supply
Beckett graded 71 of these 2005 SP Authentic Aaron Rodgers cards. Of them, 12 reached gem mint 9.5, 38 were mint 9, and the rest scored 8.5 or below. With only 99 in existence and 12 at BGS 9.5, their rarity is evident. The premium SP Authentic brand by Upper Deck and on-card autographs add to their value.
2005 SP Authentic Aaron Rodgers RC Market Dynamics
In September 2023, PWCC Auctions sold a gem mint for $9,600, a drop from the $34,800 in September 2022. Current BGS 9 or SGC versions hover around $6,000 to $7,000.
#1. 2005 Playoff Contenders Aaron Rodgers RC Auto #101
Aaron Rodgers Holy Grail Autograph Rookie Card
Among modern football cards, the Playoff Contenders Rookie Ticket Autograph is often hailed as the Holy Grail by football card collectors. The 2005 edition features a foil sticker auto; though it’s not an on-card autograph, Rodgers’s signature, rendered in bold black ink, distinctly stands out, enhancing the card’s visual appeal.
For fans, investors, and collectors of Aaron Rodgers memorabilia, this card represents the pinnacle of his rookie card portfolio, especially the even more elusive Playoff Ticket parallels.
2005 Playoff Contenders Aaron Rodgers RC Supply
Out of the 2005 Aaron Rodgers Rookie Ticket Autographs, PSA has graded a total of 138. Among these, 37 have achieved the gem mint 10 grade, 59 have been rated as mint 9, and the remainder fall at 8.5 or below.
2005 Playoff Contenders Aaron Rodgers RC Value
The most notable sale occurred in January 2022, when a PSA 10 graded Aaron Rodgers Playoff Contenders Rookie Ticket Autograph was sold by PWCC Auctions for a staggering $52,800. However, a similar PSA 10 card was sold by PWCC Auctions in July 2023 for $13,200.
This decline in value might be attributed to Rodgers’s trade to the Jets and a season-ending injury early in the season. Given these fluctuations, the question arises: Is it the right time to buy or sell? Share your thoughts in the comments below.
Conclusion
Alright, folks! 🎉 There you have it – an in-depth look at some of the most sought-after Aaron Rodgers rookie cards on the market. From the budget-friendly value option to the elite blue-chip pieces, there’s something here for collectors and investors of all levels.
Stay Informed and Trust Your Instincts
Remember, the sports card market is dynamic, influenced by player performance, market trends, and good old-fashioned supply and demand. So, whether you’re hunting for a piece of memorabilia from one of the NFL’s greats or looking to invest for the future, it’s essential to stay informed and trust your instincts.
Did this breakdown light a fire for your next acquisition? Or maybe you’ve got an insider scoop or predictions about where the market is headed? Drop those thoughts in the comments below! 🔥
Final Note
Before signing off, don’t forget to keep an eye on Rodgers’ journey – both on and off the gridiron. Because, as history has shown, a single play, trade, or season can significantly sway these card values!
From a young age, Matt dove deep into sports card valuation, turning to esteemed price guides like Beckett and Tuff Stuff. Eventually he extended to Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, and Yu-Gi-Oh!. With a vision to sustain and nurture the hobby he loved, Matt established the ‘Graded Card Investor’ YouTube channel and website. He aims to foster a healthy community and offer invaluable insights to those entering the world of sports cards and TCGs. His depth of understanding, from the card market’s 2020 pinnacle to its 1990s valleys, is consistently fortified by meticulous research.
