When you click on links and make a purchase, this can result in us earning a commission at no additional cost to you. Affiliate programs include eBay Partner Network and Amazon. Thank you!
Top 15 Bart Starr football card list best value and prices

Top 15 Bart Starr Football Card List – Most Valuable & Best Cards

Hey guys, Matt here with  Graded Card Investor and today I’m listing of the top 15 highest-selling and recently sold Bart Starr football cards. Now, for the most part these cards are all graded by PSA and are in either near mint to mint 8 or mint 9 condition.

This list goes in order from the year and not the value so pay attention to the sales prices and PSA population (supply). Make sure to check back for updates and comment at the bottom what Bart Starr football card you think should be on the list.

Without any further ado, let’s jump into this list!


1970 Topps Bart Starr #30

  • Grade: PSA 9
  • Auction House: eBay
  • Sale Date: December 2023
  • Sale Price: $315
1970 Topps Bart Starr football card graded PSA 9
Click to shop the 1970 Topps Bart Starr football card on eBay
1970 Topps Bart Starr card #30 backside
Back side of the card

➡️ Check The Value Of The 1970 Topps Bart Starr Card On eBay

Market Analysis: 1970 Topps Bart Starr Card #30

  • Supply: PSA has graded 1,472 of the 1970 Topps Bart Starr cards with 12 grading gem mint 10, 87 mint 9, 312 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
  • PSA 9 Value:
    • PSA 9 sold by PWCC Auctions Auctions in July 2023 for $372
    • PSA 9 sold on eBay in December 2023 for $315
  • PSA 8 Value:
    • PSA 8 sold on eBay in December 2023 for $153

1969 Topps Bart Starr #215

  • Grade: PSA 9
  • Auction House: eBay
  • Sale Date: December 2023
  • Sale Price: $1,930
1969 Topps Bart Starr football card graded PSA 9
Click to shop the 1969 Topps Bart Starr football card on eBay
1969 Topps Bart card #215
Back side of the card

➡️ Check The Value Of The 1969 Topps Bart Starr Card On eBay

Market Analysis: 1969 Topps Bart Starr Card #215

  • Supply: PSA has graded 1,063 of the 1969 Topps Bart Starr cards with none grading gem mint 10, 31 mint 9, 252 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
  • PSA 9 Value:
    • PSA 9 sold by Heritage Auctions in July 2023 for $1,740
    • PSA 9 sold on eBay in December 2023 for $1,930
  • PSA 8 Value:
    • PSA 8 sold on eBay in December 2023 for $255

1968 Topps Bart Starr #1

  • Grade: PSA 9
  • Auction House: Heritage auctions
  • Sale Date: January 2023
  • Sale Price: $3,000
1968 Topps Bart Starr football card graded PSA 9
Click to shop the 1968 Topps Bart Starr football card on eBay
1968 Topps Bart Starr card #1
Back side of the card

➡️ Check The Value Of The 1968 Topps Bart Starr Card On eBay

Market Analysis: 1968 Topps Bart Starr Card #1

  • Supply: PSA has graded 1,097 of the 1968 Topps Bart Starr cards with 1 grading gem mint 10, 28 mint 9, 129 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
  • PSA 9 Value:
    • PSA 9 sold on eBay in January 2023 for $3,000
    • PSA 9 sold on eBay in January 2022 for $3,120
  • PSA 8 Value:
    • PSA 8 sold on eBay in December 2023 for $456

1967 Philadelphia Bart Starr #82

  • Grade: PSA 8
  • Auction House: eBay
  • Sale Date: January 2024
  • Sale Price: $425
1967 Philadelphia Bart Starr #82 PSA 8
Click to shop the 1967 Philadelphia Bart Starr football card on eBay
1967 Philadelphia Bart Starr #82 PSA 8 back side
Back side of the card

➡️ Check The Value Of The 1967 Philadelphia Bart Starr Card On eBay

Market Analysis: 1967 Philadelphia Bart Starr Card #82

  • Supply: PSA has graded 529 of the 1967 Philadelphia Bart Starr cards with none grading gem mint 10, 5 mint 9, 112 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
  • PSA 8 Value:
    • PSA 8 sold on eBay in January 2024 for $425
  • PSA 7 Value:
    • PSA 7 sold on eBay in January 2024 for $110

1966 Philadelphia Bart Starr #88

  • Grade: PSA 9
  • Auction House: Heritage Auctions
  • Sale Date: November 2022
  • Sale Price: $1,800
1966 Philadelphia Bart Starr football card graded PSA 9
Click to shop the 1966 Philadelphia Bart Starr football card on eBay
1966 Philadelphia Bart Starr card #88
Back side of the card

➡️ Check The Value Of The 1966 Philadelphia Bart Starr Card On eBay

Market Analysis: 1966 Philadelphia Bart Starr Card #88

  • Supply: PSA has graded 801 of the 1966 Philadelphia Bart Starr cards with none grading gem mint 10, 26 mint 9, 158 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
  • PSA 9 Value:
    • PSA 9 sold by Heritage Auctions in November 2022 for $1,800
  • PSA 8 Value:
    • PSA 8 sold on eBay in January 2024 for $175

1965 Philadelphia Bart Starr #81

  • Grade: PSA 9
  • Auction House: Heritage Auctions
  • Sale Date: January 2023
  • Sale Price: $3,960
1965 Philadelphia Bart Starr football card graded PSA 9
Click to shop the 1965 Philadelphia Bart Starr football card on eBay
1965 Philadelphia Bart Starr card #81
Back side of the card

➡️ Check The Value Of The 1965 Philadelphia Bart Starr Card On eBay

Market Analysis: 1965 Philadelphia Bart Starr Card #81

  • Supply: PSA has graded 579 of the 1965 Philadelphia Bart Starr cards with none grading gem mint 10, 15 mint 9, 124 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
  • PSA 9 Value:
    • PSA 9 sold by Heritage Auctions in January 2023 for $3,960
  • PSA 8 Value:
    • PSA 8 sold on eBay in December 2023 for $297

1964 Philadelphia Bart Starr #79

  • Grade: PSA 9
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Sale Date: April 2021
  • Sale Price: $610
1964 Philadelphia Bart Starr football card graded PSA 9
Click to shop the 1964 Philadelphia Bart Starr football card on eBay
1964 Philadelphia Bart Starr card #79
Back side of the card

➡️ Check The Value Of The 1964 Philadelphia Bart Starr Card On eBay

Market Analysis: 1964 Philadelphia Bart Starr Card #79

  • Supply: PSA has graded 632 of the 1964 Philadelphia Bart Starr cards with 1 grading gem mint 10, 30 mint 9, 184 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
  • PSA 9 Value:
    • PSA 9 sold by PWCC Auctions in April 2021 for $610
  • PSA 8 Value:
    • PSA 8 sold on eBay in January 2024 for $162

1963 Topps Bart Starr #86

  • Grade: PSA 8
  • Auction House: Robert Edward Auctions
  • Sale Date: April 2023
  • Sale Price: $1,260
1963 Topps Bart Starr football card graded PSA 8
Click to shop the 1963 Topps Bart Starr football card on eBay
1963 Topps Bart Starr card #86
Back side of the card

➡️ Check The Value Of The 1963 Topps Bart Starr Football Card On eBay

Market Analysis: 1963 Topps Bart Starr Football Card #86

Supply: PSA has graded 697 of the 1963 Topps Bart Starr cards with none grading gem mint 10, 4 mint 9, 69 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.

  • PSA 8 Value:
    • PSA 8 sold by Robert Edward Auctions in April 2023 for $1,260
    • PSA 8 sold by PWCC Auctions in April 2021 for $898
  • PSA 7 Value:
    • PSA 7 sold by PWCC Auctions in November 2022 for $276

1962 Topps Bart Starr #63

  • Grade: PSA 8
  • Auction House: Robert Edward Auctions
  • Sale Date: October 2022
  • Sale Price: $1,860
1962 Topps Bart Starr football card graded PSA 8
Click to shop the 1962 Topps Bart Starr football card on eBay
1962 Topps Bart Starr card #63
Back side of the card

➡️ Check The Value Of The 1962 Topps Bart Starr Football Card On eBay

Market Analysis: 1962 Topps Bart Starr Football Card #63

Supply: PSA has graded 787 of the 1962 Topps Bart Starr cards with none grading gem mint 10, 3 mint 9, 37 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.

  • PSA 8 Value:
    • PSA 8 sold by Robert Edward Auctions in October 2022 for $1,860
    • PSA 8 sold by Memory Lane, Inc. in December 2021 for $1,886
  • PSA 7 Value:
    • PSA 7 sold by PWCC Auctions in November 2022 for $300

1961 Fleer Bart Starr #88

  • Grade: PSA 9
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Sale Date: October 2022
  • Sale Price: $1,770
1961 Fleer Bart Starr football card graded PSA 9
Click to shop the 1961 Fleer Bart Starr football card on eBay
1961 Fleer Bart Starr card #88
Back side of the card

➡️ Check The Value Of The 1961 Fleer Bart Starr Football Card On eBay

Market Analysis: 1961 Fleer Bart Starr Football Card #88

  • Supply: PSA has graded 458 of the 1961 Fleer Bart Starr cards with 1 grading gem mint 10, 33 mint 9, 110 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
  • PSA 9 Value:
    • PSA 9 sold by PWCC Auctions in October 2022 for $1,770
  • PSA 8 Value:
    • PSA 8 sold by Robert Edward Auctions in May 2023 for $450

1961 Topps Bart Starr #39

  • Grade: PSA 9
  • Auction House: Robert Edward Auctions
  • Sale Date: April 2023
  • Sale Price: $2,040
1961 Topps Bart Starr football card graded PSA 9
Click to shop the 1961 Topps Bart Starr football card on eBay
1961 Topps Bart Starr card #39
Back side of the card

➡️ Check The Value Of The 1961 Topps Bart Starr Football Card On eBay

Market Analysis: 1961 Topps Bart Starr Football Card #39

  • Supply: PSA has graded 782 of the 1961 Topps Bart Starr cards with none grading gem mint 10, 22 mint 9, 154 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
  • PSA 9 Value:
    • PSA 9 sold by Robert Edward Auctions in April 2023 for $2,040
  • PSA 8 Value:
    • PSA 8 sold on eBay in December 2023 for $281

1960 Topps Bart Starr #51

  • Grade: PSA 9
  • Auction House: Heritage Auctions
  • Sale Date: November 2022
  • Sale Price: $4,200
1960 Topps Bart Starr football card graded PSA 9
Click to shop the 1960 Topps Bart Starr football card on eBay
1960 Topps Bart Starr card #51
Back side of the card

➡️ Check The Value Of The 1960 Topps Bart Starr Football Card On eBay

Market Analysis: 1960 Topps Bart Starr Football Card #51

  • Supply: PSA has graded 1,377 of the 1960 Topps Bart Starr cards with 3 grading gem mint 10, 29 mint 9, 233 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
  • PSA 9 Value:
    • PSA 9 sold by Heritage Auctions in November 2022 for $4,200
    • PSA 9 sold by PWCC Auctions in April 2020 for $1,413
  • PSA 8 Value:
    • PSA 8 sold on eBay in January 2024 for $280

1959 Topps Bart Starr #23

  • Grade: PSA 9
  • Auction House: Heritage Auctions
  • Sale Date: January 2023
  • Sale Price: $4,440
1959 Topps Bart Starr football card graded PSA 9
Click to shop the 1959 Topps Bart Starr football card on eBay
1959 Topps Bart Starr card #23
Back side of the card

➡️ Check The Value Of The 1959 Topps Bart Starr Football Card On eBay

Market Analysis: 1959 Topps Bart Starr Football Card #23

  • Supply: PSA has graded 1,492 of the 1959 Topps Bart Starr cards with 3 grading gem mint 10, 29 mint 9, 233 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
  • PSA 9 Value:
    • PSA 9 sold by Heritage Auctions in January 2023 for $4,440
    • PSA 9 sold by PWCC Auctions in May 2020 for $1,913
  • PSA 8 Value:
    • PSA 8 sold on eBay in January 2024 for $417

1958 Topps Bart Starr #66

  • Grade: PSA 8
  • Auction House: eBay
  • Sale Date: November 2023
  • Sale Price: $785
1958 Topps Bart Starr football card graded PSA 9
Click to shop the 1958 Topps Bart Starr football card on eBay
1958 Topps Bart Starr card #66
Back side of the card

➡️ Check The Value Of The 1958 Topps Bart Starr Football Card On eBay

Market Analysis: 1958 Topps Bart Starr Football Card #66

  • Supply: PSA has graded 1,853 of the 1958 Topps Bart Starr cards with 1 grading gem mint 10, 6 mint 9, 155 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
  • PSA 8 Value:
    • PSA 8 sold on eBay in November 2023 for $785
    • PSA 8 sold by PWCC Auctions in August 2023 for $840
  • PSA 7 Value:
    • PSA 7 sold on eBay in January 2024 for $350

1957 Topps Bart Starr RC #119

  • Grade: PSA 8
  • Auction House: Heritage Auctions
  • Sale Date: August 2023
  • Sale Price: $15,000
1957 Topps Football Bart Starr ROOKIE #119 PSA 8
Click to shop the 1957 Topps Bart Starr rookie card on eBay
1957 Topps Football Bart Starr ROOKIE #119 PSA 8 back side
Back side of the card

➡️ Check The Value Of The 1957 Topps Bart Starr Rookie Card On eBay

Market Analysis: 1957 Topps Bart Starr Rookie Card #119

  • Supply: PSA has graded 2,335 of the 1957 Topps Bart Starr rookie cards with none grading gem mint 10, 3 mint 9, 94 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
  • PSA 8 Value:
    • PSA 8 sold by Heritage Auctions in August 2023 for $15,000
    • PSA 8 sold by PWCC Auctions in October 2022 for $15,600
  • PSA 7 Value:
    • PSA 7 sold on eBay in January 2024 for $3,110

Conclusion

Diving into the world of Bart Starr football card collecting offers not only enjoyment but also potential financial rewards. As interest in vintage football cards swells, mirroring the trend seen in vintage baseball cards, the value of cards from icons like Bart Starr is likely to climb.

The exact moment for a surge in prices remains a mystery, but securing high-grade cards now could be a shrewd investment for the days ahead. While passion should be at the heart of collecting, always ensure your financial boundaries are respected. The value you place on a card might differ from another collector’s perception. Whether they value it higher or lower is unpredictable. Above all, relish the journey of collecting and remaining patient. Here’s to the joy of the chase!

1 thought on “Top 15 Bart Starr Football Card List – Most Valuable & Best Cards”

  1. Hey Matt, long time Sam, and even equally as long I subscriber, I actually just picked up and amazing 1958 Topps Bart Starr #66
    I am building my collection of vintage but I’m getting the Jim Brown rookie that’s from the same set tomorrow. I really really really really love to have your opinion on. Should I send vintage to SGC? Also I have a real Star card, Michael Jordan, 86 Court king and it is very very real And I cannot see why this wouldn’t get a PSA in because it’s amazing. I have a ton of high dollar cards that I need to submit. I don’t have anything to keep them in and that Cayce is amazing if you would reach out to me on my email it’s Ryanporter1983@gmail.com . I have a seven-year-old little girl and two little dogs, and one of my dogs chewed up a BGS Peyton Manning rookie. Luckily the card was not damaged, but the corner of the slab was really messed up. Anyway, I mean I super super grateful for all of your hard work and content it has helped me since pre-pandemic with a lot of different questions also yeah either way I mean I would love to have the case but I would much rather get some of your input on who you recommend suggesting submitting to Wint and that kind of thing anyway, keep up the great work man thanks for always putting the content out for us. The hobby is a better place virtually, and physically because of that content. Hope to hear from you soon.
    Ryan porter

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *