When you click on links and make a purchase, this can result in us earning a commission at no additional cost to you. Affiliate programs include eBay Partner Network and Amazon. Thank you!
Patrick Mahomes rookie card list of top 20 to buy now with value

Top 20 Patrick Mahomes Rookie Cards – Price Guide & Values

Graded Card Investor’s Deep Dive: Patrick Mahomes Rookie Cards

Breakdown: Mahomes’ Rise to Stardom

Hey, everyone, Graded Card Investor here! Let’s unpack Patrick Mahomes’ journey from those Texas playfields to NFL glory. If you’ve been tracking his progress since the Whitehouse High days and later at Texas Tech University, you know his value isn’t just about the touchdowns – it’s about the whole story.

Mahomes’ Rookie Card Breakdown:

In the sports card world, we’ve seen the market just explode in recent times. Now, what’s catching my eye? That’s right, Mahomes’ rookie cards. It’s not just about nostalgia; it’s about snagging a piece of a legend in the making. Think of it as holding onto a piece of sports history with solid ROI potential.

Potential Returns and the Hype Train:

Traditional stocks, bonds, they’re cool and all, but rookie cards, especially when we talk about a player of Mahomes’ caliber, are on a whole different level. Every touchdown, every play-off, it’s like watching the value of your investment grow in real-time.

Risk vs Reward: What to Watch Out For

Now, let’s keep it 100. Every investment avenue comes with its ups and downs. In our world, that means counterfeit cards, market shifts, and player popularity spikes (or dips). If you’re thinking of going big on Mahomes, diversify your holdings. Don’t just bet on one player or one card type. Here are the top Patrick Mahomes rookie cards to consider investing in today.

➡️ Choose Your Investment Level

➡️ Jump to the High Rollers Cards

SET SOLD DATE SALE PRICE
PANINI ORIGINS 10/2023 $7,930
PANINI CONTENDERS OPTIC 10/2023 $12,600
PANINI CONTENDERS 3/2023 $54,000
PANINI FLAWLESS 8/2023 $66,000
PANINI NATIONAL TREASURES 8/2023 $193,000

#20. 2017 Panini Playoff Patrick Mahomes RC

  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Panini Playoff
  • Player: Patrick Mahomes
  • Card Number: #204
  • Grade: PSA 10
  • Sold Date: April 2023
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Price: $336
2017 Panini Playoff Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE #204 PSA 10 GEM MINT
2017 Panini Playoff Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card
2017 Panini Playoff Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE #204 PSA 10 GEM MINT BACK SIDE
Back side of the card

➡️ Compare prices of this Mahomes RC on eBay

2017 Panini Playoff Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card

The 2017 Panini Playoff collection presents a relatively cost-effective avenue to own a Patrick Mahomes rookie card. While Panini’s Playoff range might not be the pinnacle in terms of card value, it does offer an intriguing selection of rare parallels that are worth a collector’s attention.

PSA Population Report

From the PSA’s evaluations, 1,175 of Mahomes’ Playoff base set rookie cards have been graded.
The breakdown is noteworthy:

  • 790 have clinched the gem mint 10 distinction
  • 298 achieved mint 9
  • The remaining cards have been graded at PSA 8.5 or below.

For those aiming to amplify their investment, it’s prudent to hunt for the more scarce parallels in this set. They represent promising opportunities for value appreciation.

Available Parallels:

  • Goal Line
  • Red Zone
  • Kickoff, limited to 199 copies
  • 1st Down, capped at 99 copies
  • 2nd Down, restricted to 49 copies
  • 3rd Down, with only 25 in existence
  • 4th Down, a tighter limit of 10 copies
  • Touchdown, the most elusive at a solitary 1/1.

#19. 2017 Panini Patrick Mahomes RC

  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Panini
  • Player: Patrick Mahomes
  • Card Number: #104
  • Grade: PSA 10
  • Sold Date: October 2023
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Price: $372
2017 Panini Football Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE #104 PSA 10 GEM MINT
2017 Panini Phoenix Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card
2017 Panini Football Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE #104 PSA 10 GEM MINT BACK SIDE
Back side of the card

➡️ Compare prices of this Mahomes RC on eBay

2017 Panini Football Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card

The 2017 Panini Football collection delves deep into a captivating medieval theme, providing NFL aficionados a plethora of choices. Yet, apart from the brand name gleaming in foil, this more budget-friendly offering is somewhat sparse on the design front. Nonetheless, it’s a viable choice for those eyeing numerous parallels with limited printings.

Parallels to Ponder: This set is adorned with a range of parallels rooted in the medieval theme:

  • Chainmail Armor
  • Knight’s Templar
  • Shining Armor
  • Bravery #/199 (exclusive to Blaster packs)
  • Chivalry #/199 (found in Fat Packs)
  • Sacrifice #/199 (specific to Retail Boxes)
  • Blue Knight #/99
  • Red Knight #/49
  • Gold Knight #/10
  • The elusive Black Knight 1/1

Grading Breakdown: When it comes to grading, PSA evaluated 1,734 of the Mahomes rookie cards from this 2017 Panini collection. A detailed look reveals:

  • 885 of them gleaming with a gem mint 10 grade
  • 677 secured a solid mint 9
  • 120 cards received a near-mint to mint 8 grade

For those on a budget but still desiring a piece of Mahomes’ legacy, this Panini set might be the perfect blend of affordability and variety.


#18. 2017 Panini Rookies & Stars Patrick Mahomes RC

  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Panini Rookies & Stars
  • Player: Patrick Mahomes
  • Card Number: #201
  • Grade: PSA 10
  • Sold Date: March 2023
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Price: $408
2017 Panini Rookies & Stars Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE #201 PSA 10 GEM MINT
2017 Panini Rookies & Stars Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card
2017 Panini Rookies & Stars Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE #201 PSA 10 GEM MINT BACK SIDE
Back side of the card

➡️ Compare prices of this Mahomes RC on eBay

2017 Panini Rookies & Stars Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card

The 2017 Panini Rookies & Stars football collection, available in both retail and hobby formats, offers an accessible entry point for those looking to add a Patrick Mahomes rookie card to their portfolio. While the base R & S set doesn’t necessarily stand out in terms of distinctiveness, it does boast some exclusive parallels that are only accessible via the hobby version.

Highlighted Parallels:

  • Red & Blue, limited to 25 copies
  • Black & Blue, even rarer with just 5 copies
  • Gold Prizm, capped at 10 copies

For those seeking something unique within this set, Mahomes’ Longevity Signatures is a promising contender. It’s laden with options that are both relatively scarce and have a high collectible appeal.

Population Report: PSA’s evaluations show that 1,952 of the 2017 Panini Rookies & Stars Patrick Mahomes base rookie cards have been graded. Here’s the grading breakdown:

  • 1,227 achieved the coveted gem mint 10 status
  • 509 secured a mint 9
  • 126 were graded as near-mint to mint 8

#17. 2017 Panini Phoenix Patrick Mahomes RC

  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Panini Phoenix
  • Player: Patrick Mahomes
  • Card Number: #104
  • Grade: PSA 10
  • Sold Date: March 2023
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Price: $492
2017 Panini Phoenix Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE #104 PSA 10 GEM MINT
2017 Panini Phoenix Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card
2017 Panini Phoenix Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE #104 PSA 10 GEM MINT BACK SIDE
Back side of the card

➡️ Compare prices of this Mahomes RC on eBay

2016 Panini Phoenix Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card

Launched exclusively for football in 2016, the Panini Phoenix series quickly garnered attention for its luminous foil finish combined with meticulously crafted player visuals and branding.

Grading Insights: The Mahomes rookie card from the Phoenix collection boasts a modest PSA population, with a mere 382 graded in total.

Looking into the specifics:

  • 152 are gleaming with a gem mint 10 grade
  • 202 hold a reputable mint 9
  • 26 cards achieved a near-mint to mint 8 grade

Why Panini Phoenix?

While Panini Phoenix might be a recent entrant in the collecting sphere, it’s steadily etching its mark. Distinctive for its foil backdrop intertwined with modern geometric patterns, the series also hosts a range of short-printed parallels, beckoning collectors.

Parallels to Pursue

A myriad of parallels enrich this set, with Color Burst being a standout. The spectrum of parallels is also delineated by rarity and hue, spanning from Red (#/299), Pink (#/199), Purple (#/149), Orange (#/99), Yellow (#/75), Green (#/25), to the ultra-rare Black (#/10) and the exclusive Blue (1/1).

For those on the hunt for something truly singular: Printing Plates in Black, Cyan, Magenta, and Yellow are the pinnacle, each a 1/1.

With a reasonable entry price tag of $492 for one of the 152 PSA 10s, it might just be the golden hour to secure one. While Panini Phoenix might not yet have a legion of devoted collectors, its latent potential suggests it’s one to watch for possible future value augmentation.


#16
2017 Panini Donruss
Patrick Mahomes rookie card #327
PSA 10 sold for $850

2017 Panini Donruss Patrick Mahomes rookie card #327 graded PSA 10
Check the value of the 2017 Panini Donruss Patrick Mahomes rookie card on eBay

2017 Panini Donruss

Panini Donruss is at the top of the list for lower-end products. The Donruss brand has been in the hobby since the 80s, and most collectors are familiar with it. Secondly, Panini incorporated the Rated Rookie logo from the early 90s Donruss baseball card set, a set that most 90s kids collected and opened.

This set is popular amongst collectors and has firmly held its value. High-grade examples are a great option for budget collectors.

Population Report

Panini Donruss is available in both retail and hobby products and, due to its popularity and availability, has a lot more in PSA population reports. PSA graded 6,936 of the Donruss Patrick Mahomes rookie cards. Of those submitted, 1,231 graded gem mint 10 and 4,137 mint 9, the rest fell under PSA 8 and below.

Parallel Cards

Aqueous Test, Press Proofs Blue, Press Proofs Bronze, Press Proofs Green, Press Proofs Red, Press Proofs Silver (#/100), Press Proofs Silver Die Cut (#/75), Press Proofs Gold (#/50), Season Stat Line (#/41), Press Proofs Gold Die Cut (#/25), Jersey Number (#/15), Press Proofs Black (#/10), Press Proofs Black Die Cut (#1/1).


#15
2017 Panini Crown Royale
Patrick Mahomes rookie card #84
PSA 10 sold for $860

2017 Panini Crown Royale Patrick Mahomes rookie card #84 graded PSA 10
Shop the 2017 Panini Crown Royale Patrick Mahomes rookie card on eBay

2017 Panini Crown Royale

The 2017 Panini Crown Royale Football card set contains 100 base cards, including 80 veterans and 20 rookies. Rookie cards come one per pack. Parallels include Bronze (#/299), Pink (#/249), Holo Gold (#/175), Light Blue (#/99), and Platinum (#/49).

Crown Royale was introduced by Pacific trading cards in 1995 and was distinguishable by the die-cut crown edges. Panini decided not to include the die-cut edges in their football card set and had the crown printed in the background.

To veteran collectors, not having die-cut edges on Crown Royale cards removes a lot of appeal to the set. However, Panini did incorporate the Crown Royale logo and dominating crown in the design.

Population Report

PSA graded 833 of the 2017 Crown Royale Patrick Mahomes rookies. Of those submitted, 244 graded gem mint 10 and 464 graded mint 9.


#14. 2017 Panini Donruss Optic Patrick Mahomes RC

  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Panini Donruss Optic
  • Player: Patrick Mahomes
  • Card Number: #177
  • Grade: PSA 10
  • Sold Date: October 2023
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Price: $990
2017 Donruss Optic Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE #177 PSA 10 GEM MINT
2017 Panini Donruss Optic Patrick Mahomes Rated Rookie Card #177
2017 Donruss Optic Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE #177 PSA 10 GEM MINT BACK SIDE
Back side of the card

➡️ Compare prices of this Mahomes RC on eBay

2017 Panini Donruss Optic

Introduced to the collector’s world in 2016, the Panini Donruss Optic series quickly ignited interest, primarily because of its chromium finish resembling the Topps Chrome cards. This modern touch on the traditional paper Donruss design resonates well with collectors, making it a sought-after addition.

One of its standout features is the extensive range of parallels with varying print runs, catering to the diverse interests of hobbyists. The 2017 Optic Patrick Mahomes rookie card stands out as a particularly noteworthy investment, especially given its price adjustment from an initial $3,000 in early 2021.

Population Report:

Out of the 8,118 PSA-graded 2017 Optic Patrick Mahomes rookie cards: ➡️ Check population numbers

  • 4,161 received a gem mint 10 grade.
  • 3,493 achieved a mint 9 grade.

If you’re considering a submission, the probability of securing a gem mint 10 grade stands at 51%. A parallel worth noting is the Red/Yellow, not only because it aligns with the Kansas City Chiefs’ signature red but also due to its unexpectedly low population numbers. A total of 1,773 have been submitted to PSA, with 909 receiving a gem mint 10.

Donruss Optic Parallels:

  • Standard: Bronze, Holo, Lime, Pink, Red/Yellow, White Sparkle.
  • Numbered: Aqua (#/299), Orange (#/199), Blue (#/149), Red (#/99), Purple (#/50), Black (#/25), Gold (#/10), Green (#/5), Gold Vinyl (#1/1).

#13
2017 Panini Select
Patrick Mahomes rookie card #103
PSA 10 sold for $1,260

2017 Panini Select Patrick Mahomes rookie card #103 graded PSA 10
Shop the 2017 Panini Select Patrick Mahomes rookie card on eBay

2017 Panini Select

Panini Select is a newer set introduced by Panini in 2013. Select is an exclusive hobby product; therefore, it doesn’t have as much popularity as the sets available in both retail and hobby. Furthermore, the set consists of multiple tiers with various rarities, confusing the newer collector to grasp.

However, with Panini continuing the Select series and introducing a retail version in 2022, its popularity could increase. Select falls behind Prizm and ahead of Optic in popularity, the other two leaders of the upper mid-tier sets.

Population Report

PSA graded 862 of the 2017 Select Patrick Mahomes rookie cards. Of those submitted, 463 graded gem mint 10. His #247 field-level SSP rookie has significantly less graded, with 162 submitted and 91 in gem mint 10 conditions.

Panini Select Parallel Cards

Consider investing in parallels such as the Silver, Tri-Color (#/199), Blue (#/149), Maroon (#/99), Orange (#/49), Tie-Dye (#/25), Pink (#/10), Gold (#/10), Green (#/5), Black (#1/1).


#12
2017 Panini Donruss Elite
Patrick Mahomes rookie card #155
PSA 10 recently sold for $2,214

2017 Panini Donruss Elite Patrick Mahomes rookie card #155 graded PSA 10
Shop the 2017 Panini Donruss Elite Patrick Mahomes rookie card on eBay

2017 Panini Donruss Elite

Panini Donruss Elite has a couple of things going for it regarding collectability. Firstly, the base rookies are limited to 499 copies. Secondly, the design has a modern touch with a nice foil finish. Lastly, Panini created the Donruss Elite set in the early 90s Donruss Elite baseball card set and football card sets from the early 2000s.

Many collectors are familiar with the name, resulting in more brand awareness. There are numerous parallels and die-cuts with lower print runs to consider buying.

Population Report

Of the 499 Patrick Mahomes Donruss Elite rookie cards printed, PSA graded 93. Of those submitted, 23 graded gem mint 10, 60 mint 9, and 7 near-mint to mint 8.

Donruss Elite Parallel Cards

Consider investing in parallels such as the Green, Red (#/149), Purple (#/99), Aspirations (#/85), Orange (#/25), Aspirations Die Cut (#/24), Status Dies Cut (#/24), Blue (#/15), Status (#/15), Gold (#1/1)


#11. 2017 Panini Plates & Patches Patrick Mahomes RC Patch Autograph

  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Panini Plates & Patches
  • Player: Patrick Mahomes
  • Card Number: #217
  • Grade: BGS 9
  • Sold Date: December 2022
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Price: $1,830
2017 Panini Plates & Patches Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE PATCH AUTO /50 #217 BGS 9
2017 Panini Plates & Patches Patrick Mahomes Rookie Patch Auto
2017 Panini Plates & Patches Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE PATCH AUTO /50 #217 BGS 9 BACK SIDE
Back Side of the card

➡️ Compare prices of this Mahomes RC on eBay

2017 Plates & Patches Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card

Panini’s Plates & Patches set is a distinguished collection that primarily focuses on top-tier memorabilia cards and authentic printing plates. Each hobby box unveils a set of five cards, comprising an autograph, a cherished relic, and a genuine printing plate.

While the Plates & Patches collection is relatively recent, it hasn’t yet secured its position as a prime choice for both collectors and investors. A key distinction is that the autographs are rendered on stickers rather than being directly on the card, which might affect desirability compared to on-card autographs.

Nonetheless, these cards are serial-numbered up to 50, marking them as exceptionally rare and intricate to grade.

Beckett Population Report

Beckett’s data reveals that only thirteen of the 2017 Plates & Patches Mahomes rookie patch autos have been graded. A mere 2 secured a mint 9 grade, with none surpassing this rating. The report further delineates that eight are graded at BGS 8.5, while three achieved a BGS 8 grade.

This concise population report accentuates their rarity, and the absence of any achieving gem mint condition underscores the grading challenges they present.

Rookie Patch Autograph Parallels:

  • Variants: Blue #/50 or #/25, Green #/25 or #/10, Red #/10 or #/5, and the exclusive Gold 1/1. Keep an attentive eye out for these compelling parallels.

#10. 2017 Panini Limited Patrick Mahomes Rookie Patch Auto

  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Panini Limited
  • Player: Patrick Mahomes
  • Card Number: #136
  • Serial Number: 039/149
  • Grade: BGS 8
  • Sold Date: November 2022
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Price: $2,100
2017 Panini Limited Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE PATCH AUTO /149 #136 BGS 8 NM-MT
2017 Panini Limited Patrick Mahomes Rookie Patch Auto
2017 Panini Limited Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE PATCH AUTO /149 #136 BGS 8 NM-MT BACK SIDE
Back Side of the card

➡️ Compare prices of this Mahomes RC on eBay

2017 Panini Limited Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card

In 2009, when Panini secured the coveted NFL and NBA licenses, they set in motion a journey that would give birth to the Panini Limited series. A hallmark of Panini Limited hobby boxes is their rich assortment of jerseys, patches, and autographs, spanning from legends in the Hall of Fame to contemporary rookie sensations.

Unique to this set, every rookie card is categorized under the ‘rookie patch auto subset’. These cards not only boast on-card signatures but also have serial numbers conspicuously displayed on the front. The Patrick Mahomes rookie card from this edition is an exclusive rarity, with only 149 copies in existence.

However, Panini Limited cards have a known vulnerability: their edges chip rather effortlessly, which can negatively impact their grading.

Population Report

Beckett’s analysis reveals that they’ve graded just 20 of the Panini Limited Mahomes rookie cards. The breakdown is as follows: two achieved a mint 9, eight landed an 8.5, eight secured NM-MT 8, and the remaining two were assigned NM 7.

These cards are not just exceptional finds due to their scarcity; their thick cardstock – meant to frame the prominent jersey patch – makes them notably challenging to grade.

Parallel Card Options:
For investors aiming to escalate the value of their collection, the following parallels are worth a keen eye:

  • Silver: capped at 75 copies
  • Gold: limited to 50 copies
  • Ruby: with just 10 in circulation
  • Emerald: an even rarer find with only 5 copies
  • Sapphire: the crown jewel being a solitary 1/1.

#9. 2017 Panini Prizm Patrick Mahomes Silver Prizm RC

  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Panini Prizm
  • Player: Patrick Mahomes
  • Card Number: #269
  • Grade: PSA 10
  • Sold Date: October 2023
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Price: $3,360
2017 Panini Prizm Silver Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE #269 PSA 10 GEM MINT
2017 Panini Prizm Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card Silver Prizm
2017 Panini Prizm Silver Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE #269 PSA 10 GEM MINT BACK SIDE
Back Side of the card

➡️ Compare prices of this Mahomes RC on eBay

2017 Panini Prizm Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card

The Panini Prizm football card set made its debut in 2012, quickly ascending the ranks of collector preferences. Recognized as the quintessential set for contemporary rookie cards, its valuation stands tall against its counterparts.

An interesting deviation for this set was Panini’s decision to exclude non-prizm base rookie cards. Consequently, the Silver Prizm emerges as the definitive rookie card for aficionados. PSA population figures underline a growing print volume over the years, hinting at its escalating allure. But, how many did they print in 2017?

Population Report

From the records, PSA has assessed 5,052 Patrick Mahomes Silver Prizm rookie cards. A meticulous glance reveals that 933 achieved a gem mint 10, while 2,691 earned a mint 9. For those contemplating a raw card submission to PSA, the odds of landing a gem mint grade stand at 18%.

Given these metrics, one can infer the rarity and intrinsic investment prospects of these cards, forecasting substantial appreciation in the future.

Worth noting is the exclusivity of White Sparkle parallels, reserved for Panini’s online packs.

Prizm Parallels Include:

  • Standard Tiers: Base Prizm, Blue, Disco, Green, Pink, Red, Red/White/Blue.
  • Numbered Variants: Orange #/275, Light Blue #/199, Blue Wave #/149, Green Scope #/99, Purple Crystals #/75, Red Power #/49, Camo #/25, Gold #/10, Gold Vinyl #/5, Black Finite 1/1.
  • Exclusive Editions: White Sparkle (20 copies or fewer; Online Packs), Bronze Stars (6 copies; 1st Off Line).

#8. 2017 Panini Spectra Patrick Mahomes Jersey RC Auto

  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Panini Spectra
  • Player: Patrick Mahomes
  • Card Number: #204
  • Serial Number: 56/99
  • Grade: BGS 9
  • Sold Date: October 2023
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Price: $3,600
2017 Panini Spectra Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE PATCH AUTO /99 #204 BGS 9 MINT
2017 Panini Immaculate Patrick Mahomes Rookie Jersey Autograph
2017 Panini Spectra Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE PATCH AUTO /99 #204 BGS 9 MINT BACK SIDE
Back Side of the card

➡️ Compare prices of this Mahomes RC on eBay

2017 Panini Spectra Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card

Panini introduced the Spectra series with an emphasis on flamboyant backgrounds, striking metallic motifs, and limited prints. While there’s an array of Spectra football card parallels to explore, the base set offers a more cost-effective starting point.

Given their robust card stock, Spectra cards can be prone to corner damage. The chromium finish, much like refractors, can easily accrue scratches. This makes high-grade cards right out of the pack a rarity.

Beckett’s grading history reveals this trend: out of 52 Mahomes rookie cards evaluated, only 10 achieved a 9.5 gem mint condition, 30 were graded mint 9, and the rest received 8.5 or lower.

Notably, a BGS 9 mint condition specimen was auctioned by PWCC in October 2023, fetching $3,600.

2017 Panini Spectra Parallels:

  • Standard Tiers: Neon Blue (/75), Neon Green (/50), Neon Pink (/15), Neon Black Light (/10), Neon Orange (/5).
  • Exclusive: Gold (1/1), Gold Laundry Tags – NFL Players Logo (1/1), Gold Laundry Tags – NFL Shield (1/1), Gold Laundry Tags – Nike Swoosh (1/1).

#7. 2017 Panini Immaculate Collection Patrick Mahomes RC Patch Auto

  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Panini Immaculate
  • Player: Patrick Mahomes
  • Card Number: #104
  • Serial Number: 65/99
  • Grade: BGS 8.5
  • Sold Date: November 2022
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Price: $3,720
2017 Immaculate Collection Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE PATCH AUTO /99 #104 BGS 8.5
2017 Panini Immaculate Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card Autograph
2017 Immaculate Collection Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE PATCH AUTO /99 #104 BGS 8.5 BACK SIDE
Back Side of the card

➡️ Compare prices of this Mahomes RC on eBay

2017 Panini Immaculate Collection Patrick Mahomes rookie card.

Hey collectors, let’s dive into the Panini Immaculate Collection, where we’re treated to Mahomes’ genuine on-card autograph—a breath of fresh air from those sticker autos we often see. With the base set cards numbered up to just 99, they’re already pretty limited. But if you’re chasing the rarest of the rare, keep an eye out for that Gold parallel; its print run is even rarer /10.

Now, here’s something for all you condition hunters out there: this card, with its thick cardstock and matte finish, is notorious for being easily dinged, especially on those edges and corners. Finding a high-grade version? That’s a challenge! Just to give you an idea of its rarity and value, a BGS 8.5 example was sold by PWCC Auctions in November 2022 for $3,720.


#6. 2016 Panini Select Patrick Mahomes XRC

  • Year: 2016
  • Set: Panini Select
  • Player: Patrick Mahomes
  • Card Number: #2
  • Grade: BGS 10
  • Sold Date: October 2023
  • Auction House: eBay
  • Price: $5,300
2016 Select '17 XRC Silver Prizm Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE #2 BGS 10 PRISTINE
2016 Select Patrick Mahomes XRC
2016 Select '17 XRC Silver Prizm Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE #2 BGS 10 PRISTINE BACK SIDE
Back Side of the card

➡️ Compare prices of this Mahomes RC on eBay

2016 Panini Select XRC Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card

Panini’s 2016 Select football set was ahead of its time, giving collectors a tantalizing sneak peek of the future with its introduction of the earliest Patrick Mahomes rookie card. These weren’t typical cards; Panini ingeniously inserted redemption cards – one per hobby box – representing rookie cards from the impending 2017 NFL draft class.

Population Report

Beckett’s records show that they’ve graded 286 of the Mahomes 2016 XRC rookie cards. Among these, a rarefied trio achieved the Black Label 10, eleven secured a BGS 10, and a substantial 195 reached BGS 9.5.

While these cards don’t present an overwhelming grading challenge, attaining a BGS 10 grade remains a rare accomplishment. A testament to its value, a BGS 10 Black Label example was auctioned by PWCC in February 2023, fetching an impressive $40,800.

Parallel Options to Watch: Collectors have three distinct parallels to vie for:

  • The foundational base (silver)
  • The mesmerizing Tie-Dye, limited to just 25 copies
  • The glistening Gold, capped at a mere 10 copies.

Being the pioneer, the very first Patrick Mahomes rookie card referred to as an XRC, whenever one appears on the auction block, it inevitably sparks intense competition among enthusiasts.


#5. 2017 Panini Origins Patrick Mahomes Jumbo RC Patch Auto

  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Panini Origins
  • Player: Patrick Mahomes
  • Parallel: Jumbo Patch
  • Card Number: #104
  • Grade: PSA 10
  • Sold Date: October 2023
  • Auction House: Goldin Auctions
  • Price: $7,930
2017 Panini Origins Jumbo Rookie Patch Autograph (RPA) #104 Patrick Mahomes II Signed Patch Rookie Card - PSA GEM MT 10
2017 Panini Origins Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card Autograph
2017 Panini Origins Jumbo Rookie Patch Autograph (RPA) #104 Patrick Mahomes II Signed Patch Rookie Card - PSA GEM MT 10 BACK SIDE
Back Side of the card

➡️ Compare prices of this Mahomes RC on eBay

2017 Panini Origins Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card

Panini Origins is a standout set from Panini, which resembles the look of the Topps Inception baseball cards, a beloved series that ceased production in 2015. There a variety of parallels in this series, featuring limited editions such as:

  • Red (/99)
  • Blue (/49)
  • Turquoise (/25)
  • Gold (/10)
  • Green (/5)
  • Black (1/1)

Highlighting recent market dynamics, a PSA 10 specimen of this card fetched $7,930 at a Goldin Auctions sale in October 2023. This represents a decrease from its previous sale price of $13,800 in September 2021 at a PWCC auction event. It’s worth noting that this dip is more reflective of the post-pandemic market adjustment rather than a commentary on Mahomes’ prowess; after all, Mahomes continues to dominate on the field.


#4. 2017 Panini Contenders Optic Patrick Mahomes RC Autograph

  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Panini Donruss Optic Contenders
  • Player: Patrick Mahomes
  • Card Number: #103
  • Grade: PSA 10
  • Sold Date: October 2023
  • Auction House: eBay
  • Price: $12,600
2017 Panini Contenders Optic Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE AUTO #103 PSA 10 GEM MINT
2017 Panini Contenders Optic Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card Autograph
2017 Panini Contenders Optic Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE AUTO #103 PSA 10 GEM MINT BACK SIDE
Back Side of the card

➡️ Compare prices of this Mahomes RC on eBay

2017 Panini Contenders Optic Patrick Mahomes rookie card autograph.

PWCC Auctions sold a PSA 10 example of Mahomes’ 2017 Panini Contenders Optic RC Autograph in October 2023 for $12,600. In comparison, a BGS 9.5 gem mint condition example sold in September 2023 for $9,000.

These cards feature on-card autographs and a design combining two of Panini’s more popular brands, Donruss Optic and Playoff Contenders. If you’re looking to increase your investment consider buying rarer parallels, including Red /75, Blue, /25, Gold /10, and a Gold Vinyl 1/1.


#3. 2017 Panini Contenders Patrick Mahomes RC Autograph

  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Panini Contenders
  • Player: Patrick Mahomes
  • Parallel: Autograph
  • Card Number: #303
  • Grade: BGS 10
  • Sold Date: March 2023
  • Auction House: Goldin Auctions
  • Price: $54,000
2017 Panini Contenders Rookie Ticket Autograph #303 Patrick Mahomes II Signed Rookie Card – BGS PRISTINE 10, Beckett 10
2017 Panini Contenders Optic Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card Autograph
2017 Panini Contenders Rookie Ticket Autograph #303 Patrick Mahomes II Signed Rookie Card – BGS PRISTINE 10, Beckett 10 BACK SIDE
Back Side of the card

➡️ Compare prices of this Mahomes RC on eBay

The 2017 Panini Contenders features a sought-after Patrick Mahomes rookie card with signature autographs. Parallel versions like Playoff Ticket, Championship Ticket, and Cracked Ice are rarer and hold higher values.

A BGS 10 version sold at Goldin Auctions in March 2023 for $54,000, outpacing a PSA 10 sold for $38,400 in February 2023, emphasizing BGS 10’s increasing appeal due to its scarcity.


Cracked Ice Rookie Card Autograph

  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Panini Contenders
  • Player: Patrick Mahomes
  • Parallel: Cracked Ice Autograph
  • Serial Number: 08/25
  • Card Number: #303
  • Grade: PSA 10
  • Sold Date: March 2023
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Price: $114,000
2017 Panini Contenders Cracked Ice Patrick Mahomes ROOKIE AUTO /25 #303 PSA 10
2017 Panini Contenders Optic Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card Autograph
2017 Panini Contenders Cracked Ice Patrick Mahomes ROOKIE AUTO /25 #303 PSA 10 BACK SIDE
Back Side of the card

➡️ Compare prices of this Mahomes RC on eBay

The Cracked Ice parallel auto from Panini Contenders is among Mahomes’ most coveted rookie card autographs. With only 25 copies, its flashy design combined with an on-card autograph makes it a top-tier modern-day collectible.

In April 2023, a PSA 10 example fetched $114,000 at PWCC Auctions, a decline from its December 2021 sale price of $336,000. Only two of these are graded PSA 10. If you’re in the market for one of these rare cards, consider getting one that is graded by Beckett in an 8.5 or 9 grade because they are selling between $29,000 to $40,000 right now.


#2. 2017 Panini Flawless Patrick Mahomes Rookie Patch Auto

  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Panini Flawless
  • Player: Patrick Mahomes
  • Parallel: Rookie Patch Autograph
  • Serial Number: 06/25
  • Card Number: #RP-PM
  • Grade: PSA 10
  • Sold Date: August 2023
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Price: $66,000
2017 Panini Flawless Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE PATCH AUTO /25 PSA 10 GEM MINT
2017 Panini Flawless Patrick Mahomes Rookie Patch Autograph
2017 Panini Flawless Patrick Mahomes II ROOKIE PATCH AUTO /25 PSA 10 GEM MINT BACK SIDE
Back Side of the card

➡️ Compare prices of this Mahomes RC on eBay

2017 Panini Flawless Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card

The 2017 Panini Flawless Patrick Mahomes rookie card features an authentic on-card autograph, and a three-color patch, and is limited to just 25 copies. Its vertical layout is preferred for display, and its rare color parallels are highly desired by collectors. Moreover, Panini Flawless is regarded as one of the best brands in the hobby to invest in.

PWCC Auctions sold the PSA 10 example above at auction in August 2023 for $66,000. The value is up from January 2023 when one sold for $45,600. Currently, there are just three examples graded PSA 10 gem mint condition.


#1. 2017 Panini National Treasures Patrick Mahomes Rookie Patch Auto

  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Panini National Treasures
  • Player: Patrick Mahomes
  • Parallel: Rookie Patch Autograph
  • Serial Number: 71/99
  • Card Number: #161
  • Grade: PSA 10
  • Sold Date: August 2023
  • Auction House: Goldin Auctions
  • Price: $193,000
2017 Panini National Treasures Rookie Patch Autograph (RPA) #161 Patrick Mahomes II Signed Patch Rookie Card (#71/99) - PSA GEM MT 10
2017 Panini National Treasures Patrick Mahomes Rookie Patch Autograph
2017 Panini National Treasures Rookie Patch Autograph (RPA) #161 Patrick Mahomes II Signed Patch Rookie Card (#71/99) - PSA GEM MT 10 BACK SIDE
Back Side of the card

➡️ Compare prices of this Mahomes RC on eBay

2017 Panini National Treasures Patrick Mahomes Rookie Patch Autograph: A Graded Investor’s Spotlight

Quick Facts:

  • Card Details: 2017 Panini National Treasures, Player: Patrick Mahomes, Parallel: Rookie Patch Autograph, Card Number: #161
  • Grade: PSA 10
  • Sold: August 2023 through Goldin Auctions for $193,000.
  • Card Backdrop: A highly-coveted National Treasures Rookie Patch Auto Card bearing an unblemished autograph of Patrick Mahomes.

Investment Insight:

Navigating through Patrick Mahomes’ rookie cards, the National Treasures Rookie Patch Auto Card emerges as both a visual masterpiece and a robust financial beacon. In 2018, a pristine PSA 10 variant was valued between $3,000-$4,000. Remarkably, by 2021, this figure soared to $399,750 in a Goldin Auction.

This meteoric rise underscores the card’s colossal investment trajectory. However, Goldin Auctions the PSA 10 example shown above in September 2023 for $193,066, which is down from the all-time high but still up from the 2020 value.

Design & Rarity:

The National Treasures Rookie Patch Auto card seamlessly melds artistic brilliance with exclusivity. It exhibits a radiant autograph below a portrayal of Mahomes in his NFL ensemble. The prominently tri-colored patches intricately highlight segments from Mahomes’ jersey, narrating distinct tales. Its serialized number, subtly positioned top-left, accentuates its authenticity and scarcity.

Diverse Parallels: Graded card investors should note the variety of parallels, with each edition emanating a singular allure:

  • Holo Silver (/25)
  • Stars and Stripes (/13)
  • Green Jersey Number (/15)
  • Holo Gold (/10)
  • Black (/5)
  • Red Brand Logo (/2)
  • Platinum (1/1)

Exclusive Editions: Amplifying its intrigue, the card series also flaunts 1 of 1 versions and Printing Plates, each exuding unique color gradations:

  • 1 of 1’s: Platinum, Red, Red Laundry Tag (All 1/1)
  • Printing Plates: Black, Magenta, Cyan, and Yellow (All 1/1)

For investors focusing on graded cards, this 2017 Panini National Treasures Patrick Mahomes card is undoubtedly a portfolio cornerstone.


Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card Guide

Overview: Patrick Mahomes transcends the title of a mere player; he stands as an emblem of unmatched prowess and promise. Owning his rookie card is less about possession and more about cherishing an artifact of his monumental legacy. To invest in such a card intertwines financial prudence with the profound emotional bond fans and admirers feel towards Mahomes’ illustrious journey and the grandeur of the NFL.

Frequently Asked Questions:

1. How much is a Patrick Mahomes rookie card worth?

The valuation of Patrick Mahomes’ rookie cards oscillates extensively, influenced by aspects like rarity, card condition, grading, and the presence of his autograph.

For instance, the coveted 2017 Panini National Treasures or the Panini Contenders Rookie Ticket Auto, owing to their limited availability and collector appeal, command stellar prices. Expect figures that span from several hundred to a myriad of thousands, with exceptional versions potentially exceeding these benchmarks in resale scenarios.

2. Which Mahomes cards are most lucrative?

Numerous rookie cards of Patrick Mahomes are hailed as valuable treasures, especially the ones that boast rarity, pristine condition, and esteemed grading. Noteworthy mentions encompass:

3. Which rookie card of Mahomes is considered supreme?

The definition of the “best” is subjective and pivots on individual preferences, spanning rarity, design allure, or investment trajectory. Yet, the 2017 Panini National Treasures Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card, embedding a jersey segment and an on-card signature, stands out. Esteemed by the collector realm, its combined investment and sentimental worth often designate it as a collector’s crown jewel.

4. What’s the pinnacle price a Patrick Mahomes card has fetched?

The record-holder is a 2017 National Treasures One of One sold by PWCC in a private deal July 2021. The card went to LJ’s Card shop. PWCC made a public tweet on their Twitter page about it.

3 thoughts on “Top 20 Patrick Mahomes Rookie Cards – Price Guide & Values”

  1. Pingback: Best Patrick Mahomes Cards: Top 5 Picks Every Collector Needs, According To Experts - Study Finds

  2. I’m a big fan of the Contenders Rookie Ticket Auto, and when it’s a Patrick Mahomes card, it’s even better. While the horizontal format of the variation might not be everyone’s cup of tea, the on-card autograph significantly boosts its value. Factor in the limited PSA population, and this card becomes even more appealing. If you’re considering it as an investment, I’d recommend scouting for the BGS 9 or SGC 9 examples; they often come with a more attractive buy-in price. I hope this helps. Cheers!

  3. Great article. Super insight and perspective. Also, very well written.
    Can you tell me what you think of the Contenders variation #343? Please.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *