When you click on links and make a purchase, this can result in us earning a commission at no additional cost to you. Affiliate programs include eBay Partner Network and Amazon. Thank you!
Aaron Judge rookie cards to buy now his most valuable and highest selling

Aaron Judge Rookie Card Checklist – Investing in Aaron Judge

Why invest in Aaron Judge Rookie Cards?

Hey there, fellow collectors and investors! Today, let’s talk about why you absolutely want to consider investing in Aaron Judge’s rookie cards, especially considering his incredible career stats. This guy is the real deal, and here’s why:

Reason #1: Unbelievable Rookie Season (2017)

Aaron Judge’s rookie season in 2017 was nothing short of spectacular. At the age of 25, he played 155 games, racking up 52 homers, 128 runs, and 114 RBIs with a slash line of .284/.422/.627. That’s not just Rookie of the Year material; that’s MVP-caliber performance.

Reason #2: Consistent Excellence

Judge didn’t stop at his rookie year. He’s been consistently excellent throughout his career. Check out those career averages – a .282 batting average, .396 on-base percentage, and a whopping .586 slugging percentage. That adds up to a career OPS of .982, folks!

Reason #3: Power Hitter Extraordinaire

The man’s got power, and it’s on full display with 257 career home runs. In 2017, he not only led the American League in home runs but broke Mark McGwire’s rookie record with 52 homers. And he’s kept that power game strong ever since.

Reason #4: All-Star & MVP Contender

Judge has been selected as an All-Star multiple times, proving he’s among the best in the game. He’s even been an MVP candidate, finishing second in the AL MVP race in 2017 and ranking fourth in 2021.

Reason #5: Impressive Awards & Achievements

Beyond the stats, Judge has a trophy cabinet full of awards. He’s got Rookie of the Year, Silver Slugger, and Gold Glove honors, showcasing his well-rounded skills.

Reason #6: Yankee Legacy

Being a New York Yankee comes with its own kind of prestige. Judge has become a symbol of the franchise, with a dedicated fan base and a legacy that’s still growing.

Reason #7: Strong Work Ethic & Community Involvement

Judge isn’t just a baseball superstar; he’s a role model. His strong work ethic and involvement in charitable work make him a respected figure off the field too.

In short, folks, investing in Aaron Judge’s rookie cards is a home run. With his incredible career stats, consistency, and potential for future greatness, he’s a must-have in any collector’s or investor’s portfolio. Keep an eye out for those rookie cards, especially from his record-breaking 2017 season – they’re the crown jewels of any Judge collection.

Now, without any further ado, let’s jump into this list!


#10. 2014 Bowman Draft Picks – Aaron Judge RC

  • Year: 2014
  • Set: Bowman Draft Picks
  • Player: Aaron Judge
  • Type: Refractor
  • Card Number: #CTP39
  • Grade: PSA 10
  • Sold Date: July 2023
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Price: $150
2014 Bowman Chrome Draft Refractor Aaron Judge ROOKIE #CTP-39 PSA 10 GEM MINT
Shop this Aaron Judge Rookie card on eBay
2014 Bowman Chrome Draft Refractor Aaron Judge ROOKIE #CTP-39 PSA 10 GEM MINT back
Back side of card

➡️ Compare the prices of this card on eBay

2014 Bowman Chrome Aaron Judge RC

Alright, folks, let’s dive into the world of Aaron Judge’s 2014 Bowman Chrome cards. Now, these aren’t technically his rookie cards, but they’re still worth taking a look at, and here’s why:

  • Reason #1: Second Year Cards
    These bad boys are Aaron Judge’s second-year cards, and here’s the kicker – they’re surprisingly more budget-friendly than his later cards. You’d think that being the second appearance in an officially licensed baseball card set, they’d be worth more, but that’s where you’re in for a sweet surprise.
  • Reason #2: Affordable Gems
    A PSA 10 example of one of these cards went for just $150 in a PWCC auction in July 2023. That’s quite a steal when you consider the potential these cards have.
  • Reason #3: Color Parallels Galore
    Now, if you’re into collecting those eye-catching color parallels, you’re in luck. The 2014 Bowman Chrome set offers a variety of options to choose from, including Blue /399, Gold /50, Red Wave /25, Orange /25, and even Blue Wave and base refractors that aren’t numbered.

Keep an eye out for parallels

So, folks, while these might not be Aaron Judge’s 1st Bowman or 2017 rookie cards, they’re still worth considering, especially if you’re looking to add some affordable gems with the potential to shine in your collection. Keep an eye out for those color parallels – they can really make your collection pop!


  • Year: 2014
  • Set: Bowman Draft Picks
  • Player: Aaron Judge
  • Type: Red Wave Refractor
  • Card Number: #CTP39
  • Serial Number: 14/25
  • Grade: PSA 10
  • Sold Date: February 2023
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Price: $1,080
2014 Bowman Chrome Red Wave Refractor Aaron Judge ROOKIE /25 #CTP-39 PSA 10
Shop this Aaron Judge Rookie card on eBay
2014 Bowman Chrome Red Wave Refractor Aaron Judge ROOKIE /25 #CTP-39 PSA 10 back
Back side of card

PWCC Auctions sold a 2014 Bowman Chrome Aaron Judge Red Wave refractor prospect rookie card graded SA 10 at auction in February 2023 for $1,080. These are ultra-rare and hard to find. Moreover, 2014 is Aaron Judges’ second-year card.


#9. 2017 Topps Chrome – Aaron Judge RC

  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Topps Chrome
  • Player: Aaron Judge
  • Type: Refractor
  • Card Number: #169
  • Grade: PSA 10
  • Sold Date: September 2023
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Price: $186

➡️ Compare the prices of this card on eBay

2017 Topps Chrome Aaron Judge RC

Looking to kickstart your Aaron Judge rookie card collection with a budget? Well, the 2017 Topps Chrome Aaron Judge rookie card refractor is a pretty solid way to go. Here’s why:

  • Reason #1: Affordable Entry Point:
    First off, the price tag won’t break the bank. It’s a budget-friendly option that’s perfect for getting your collection off the ground. And the best part? If Judge has a breakout season, which he’s definitely capable of, the demand for this card could soar.
  • Reason #2: Topps Chrome Prestige:
    Topps Chrome cards have a certain prestige in the collecting world. They’re the go-to choice for both collectors and investors, especially when a player like Judge is making waves in the league.
  • Reason #3: Chase Those Parallel:
    Now, if you’re feeling a bit more adventurous and want to aim for higher returns, consider hunting down the colored parallels and autographs. Sure, there’s a bit more risk involved, but the potential payoff is worth it. Keep an eye out for these options: Orange /25, Gold Wave /50, Green /99, and even some unique ones like Pink, Prism, and Negative. These can add some serious value to your collection.

So there you have it, folks. The 2017 Topps Chrome Aaron Judge rookie card refractor – an affordable, entry-level card with the potential for some exciting returns, especially if Judge continues to make waves in the league. And don’t forget to chase those colorful parallels – they’re the real gems in this collection game!


#8. 2017 Topps Chrome Update – Aaron Judge RC

  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Topps Chrome Update
  • Player: Aaron Judge
  • Type: Refractor
  • Card Number: #HTM40
  • Serial Number: 130/250
  • Grade: PSA 10
  • Sold Date: August 2023
  • Auction House: Goldin Auctions
  • Price: $200

2017 Topps Chrome Update Aaron Judge RC #HMT40

The 2017 Topps Chrome Update set features two significant rookie cards for Aaron Judge: #HMT40, his All-Star game card, and #HMT50, his rookie debut card. Both of these cards hold value and are collectible among enthusiasts with #HMT50 being the more desirable and valuable. Additionally, collectors can pursue various parallels within this set, including:

  • Refractor (serial-numbered to 250 copies)
  • X-Fractor (serial-numbered to 99 copies)
  • Gold Refractor (serial-numbered to 50 copies)
  • Red Refractor (serial-numbered to 25 copies)
  • SuperFractor (one-of-one)
  • Printing Plate (set of four for each)

  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Topps Chrome Update
  • Player: Aaron Judge
  • Type: Superfractor Autograph
  • Card Number: #HTM40
  • Serial Number: 1/1
  • Grade: BGS 9.5
  • Sold Date: September 2023
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Price: $15,000
2017 Topps Chrome Update Superfractor Aaron Judge ROOKIE AUTO 1/1 #HMT40 BGS 9.5
Shop Superfractor Cards on eBay
2017 Topps Chrome Update Superfractor Aaron Judge ROOKIE AUTO 1/1 #HMT40 BGS 9.5 back
Back side of card

PWCC Auctions sold this 2017 Topps Chrome Update Aaron Judge Superfractor rookie card autograph 1/1 in September 2023 for an astonishing $15,000.


  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Topps Chrome Update
  • Player: Aaron Judge
  • Type: Refractor
  • Card Number: #HTM50
  • Serial Number: 140/250
  • Grade: PSA 10
  • Sold Date: July 2023
  • Auction House: eBay
  • Price: $653

➡️ Compare the prices of this card on eBay


#7. 2017 Bowman Chrome – Aaron Judge RC

  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Bowman Chrome
  • Player: Aaron Judge
  • Type: Refractor
  • Card Number: #56
  • Serial Number: 430/499
  • Grade: 10
  • Sold Date: August 2023
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Price: $336

➡️ Compare the prices of this card on eBay


  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Bowman Chrome
  • Player: Aaron Judge
  • Type: Superfractor
  • Card Number: #56
  • Serial Number: 1/1
  • Grade: BGS 9.5
  • Sold Date: November 2022
  • Auction House: Goldin Auctions
  • Price: $10,261
2017 Bowman Chrome SuperFractor #96 Aaron Judge Rookie Card (#1/1) – BGS GEM MINT 9.5 back side
Back side of card

➡️ Shop Bowman Chrome Superfractors on eBay

Goldin Auctions sold the 2017 Bowman Chrome Aaron Judge Superfractor rookie card one-of-one in November 2022 for an impressive $10,261!


#6. 2013 Bowman Sterling – Aaron Judge RC

  • Year: 2013
  • Set: Bowman Sterling
  • Player: Aaron Judge
  • Type: Autograph Refractor
  • Serial Number: 043/150
  • Grade: BGS 9.5
  • Sold Date: April 2023
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Selling Price: $900

➡️ Compare the prices of this card on eBay

Bowman Sterling Aaron Judge Rookie Cards

Bowman Sterling cards are highly sought after by collectors, primarily because they feature on-card autographs, making them a valuable addition to any collection. Here are some key details to consider when it comes to Aaron Judge’s Bowman Sterling rookie cards:

  1. On-Card Autographs: One of the standout features of Bowman Sterling cards is the inclusion of on-card autographs. This adds significant value and desirability for collectors.
  2. Rare Parallels: Within the Bowman Sterling set, there are even rarer parallels that collectors can pursue. These include the Purple Refractor (/10), Blue Refractor (/25), Green Refractor (/125), and Orange Refractor (/75). If you’re looking for something exceptionally rare, consider the Gold Diamond parallel, which is serial numbered to just 3 copies.
  3. Market Performance: The sports card market is dynamic, and card values can change over time. As of April 2023, a BGS 9.5 graded Aaron Judge rookie card fetched an impressive $8,400 at auction, indicating the potential for a return on investment (ROI) with these cards.
  4. Affordability and ROI Potential: Aaron Judge’s rookie autograph cards, particularly those from Bowman Sterling, are relatively affordable compared to some other options. This affordability, coupled with the player’s performance and popularity, suggests the potential for future ROI.

Parallels

Base Refractors (#/150), Green Refractors (#/125), Ruby Refractors (#/99), Orange Refractors (#/75), Gold Refractors (#/50), Blue Refractors (#/25), Purple Refractors (#/10), Canary Diamond (#/3), Red Refractors (1/1) and Superfractors (1/1). There are also 1/1 printing plates signed by each player. 


#5. 2015 Bowman Inception – Aaron Judge RC

  • Year: 2015
  • Set: Bowman Inception
  • Player: Aaron Judge
  • Type: Autograph
  • Card Number: #PA-AJ
  • Serial Number: 75/99
  • Grade: PSA 10
  • Sold Date: August 2023
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Price: $1,170
2015 Bowman Inception Prospect Green Aaron Judge ROOKIE AUTO DNA 10 /99 PSA 10
Shop this Aaron Judge Rookie card on eBay
2015 Bowman Inception Prospect Green Aaron Judge ROOKIE AUTO DNA 10 /99 PSA 10 back side
Back side of card

➡️ Compare the prices of this card on eBay


#4. 2017 Topps Chrome – Aaron Judge RC

  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Topps Finest
  • Player: Aaron Judge
  • Type: Gold Refractor Autograph
  • Card Number: #FA-AJ
  • Grade: PSA 10
  • Sold Date: October 2022
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Price: $3,480

➡️ Compare the prices of this card on eBay


#3. 2017 Bowman’s Best – Aaron Judge RC

  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Bowman’s Best
  • Player: Aaron Judge
  • Type: Gold Refractor Autograph
  • Card Number: #B17AJ
  • Grade: BGS 9.5
  • Sold Date: April 2023
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Price: $1,170

➡️ Compare the prices of this card on eBay


#2. 2017 Topps Heritage – Aaron Judge RC

  • Year: 2017
  • Set: Topps Heritage
  • Player: Aaron Judge
  • Type: Real One Red Ink Autograph
  • Serial Number: 44/68
  • Grade: BGS 10
  • Sold Date: March 2023
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Price: $9,900

➡️ Compare the prices of this card on eBay

The Topps Heritage Red Ink Auto – A Rising Star Among Judge Collectibles

The Topps Heritage Red Ink auto card has been steadily gaining popularity among collectors of Aaron Judge memorabilia. Here’s why this vintage-inspired card is becoming a prized possession for many:

  1. Nostalgic Design: Featuring a vintage 1968 Topps design, this card captures the essence of retro baseball cards. The up-close style player portrait adds to its nostalgic appeal.
  2. Real One Special Edition Parallels: These special edition parallels are hand-numbered to just 68 copies, and they bear the player’s signature in striking red ink. This rarity makes them highly coveted among collectors.
  3. Debated Value: The value of a PSA gem mint ten-graded copy of this card can spark debates and discussions among collectors. In a recent auction, one such card fetched $3,750, but other copies have sold for significantly higher prices. Some lucky collectors managed to secure them through “buy-it-now” listings, with one selling for $5,000 and another for an astonishing $10,000!
  4. Population Report: Topps Heritage cards are known for their softer cardstock, which gives them a vintage appearance. This characteristic often makes it challenging to obtain high grades. However, despite the hand-signed and numbered nature of the Red Ink autos, a remarkable 12 out of 14 graded copies have achieved gem mint ten conditions according to PSA.

Pop 2 BGS 10 Example

One exceptional highlight is the Pop 2 BGS 10 example of Judge’s 2017 Topps Heritage Real One /68 Red Ink Rookie Auto. This card not only boasts a BGS 10 grade but also features an Auto 10, matching the card’s overall perfection. It pays homage to the design from the 1968 Topps flagship set, adding an extra layer of nostalgia and collectibility.

The allure of the Topps Heritage Red Ink auto card lies in its combination of vintage aesthetics, limited availability, and Aaron Judge’s signature in red ink. As more collectors recognize its value, it continues to climb in status and desirability within the hobby.


#1. 2013 Bowman Chrome Draft Picks – Aaron Judge RC

  • Year: 2013
  • Set: Bowman Chrome
  • Player: Aaron Judge
  • Type: Autograph Gold Refractor
  • Serial Number: 04/50
  • Grade: BGS 10
  • Sold Date: November 2022
  • Auction House: PWCC Auctions
  • Selling Price: $34,800

➡️ Compare the prices of this card on eBay

Aaron Judge Rookie Card Investment Guide

Aaron Judge’s 2013 Bowman Chrome rookie card autograph refractors are some of the most valuable and collectible rookie cards for this standout player. Here’s a breakdown of the various colored parallels and factors to consider when investing:

  1. Colored Parallels: Aaron Judge’s Bowman Chrome rookie card comes in several colored parallels, each with its own rarity and value. These include Red (/5), Purple (/10), Orange (/25), Black (/35), Gold (/50), Blue Wave (/50), Blue (/99), Green (/75), and the base autograph.
  2. Market Volatility: The values of these cards can fluctuate due to the natural volatility of the sports card market and Aaron Judge’s performance on the field. Be prepared for changes in card values over time.
  3. Budget Considerations: When investing in high-end Aaron Judge rookie cards, it’s essential to choose options that align with your budget and preferences. High-grade and rarer parallels tend to command higher prices, so make choices that fit your financial comfort zone.
  4. Patience Is Key: Whether you’re bidding in auctions or buying cards, patience is vital. Don’t rush into purchases, and try to buy cards when prices are favorable. The goal is to buy low and, if you decide to sell, sell high.

Investing in rookie cards can be an exciting venture, but it’s essential to stay informed about market trends and to make decisions that suit your long-term goals. Keep an eye on Aaron Judge’s performance, as it can impact the values of his rookie cards in the sports card market.


  • Year: 2013
  • Set: Bowman Chrome
  • Player: Aaron Judge
  • Type: Autograph Red Refractor
  • Serial Number: 04/50
  • Grade: BGS 9.5
  • Sold Date: September 2022
  • Auction House: Goldin Auctions
  • Selling Price: $180,000
2013 Bowman Chrome Draft Pick Autographs Red Refractor #BCA-AJ Aaron Judge Signed Rookie Card (#4/5) – BGS GEM MINT 9.5
Shop this Aaron Judge Rookie card on eBay
2013 Bowman Chrome Draft Pick Autographs Red Refractor #BCA-AJ Aaron Judge Signed Rookie Card (#4/5) – BGS GEM MINT 9.5 back side
Back side of card

Goldin Auctions sold this Aaron Judge 2013 Bowman Chrome Red refractor rookie card autograph in September 2022 for a staggering $180,000. Which is the highest Aaron Judge rookie card ever sold.

➡️ Read more: Highest Selling Bowman Chrome Red Refractors Recently Sold


Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Aaron Judge Rookie Cards

What Are Aaron Judge Rookie Cards?

Aaron Judge rookie cards are trading cards featuring the New York Yankees’ star outfielder from his rookie season in Major League Baseball (MLB). These cards are highly sought after by collectors and investors due to Judge’s remarkable career and potential.

When Was Aaron Judge’s Rookie Season?

Aaron Judge’s rookie season was in 2017 when he made his debut with the New York Yankees. This is the year you’ll find his official rookie cards.

Some popular sets for Aaron Judge rookie cards include 2017 Topps Chrome, 2017 Bowman Chrome, and 2017 Topps Update. These sets offer various card designs and parallels to collect.

What Are Parallels, and Why Are They Valuable?

Parallels are variations of the base card with different colors, patterns, or limited print runs. They’re valuable because they’re rarer than the base cards and often come with unique features that collectors find attractive.

What Are Some Notable Aaron Judge Rookie Card Parallels?

Some notable Aaron Judge rookie card parallels include the Orange /25, Gold Wave /50, Green /99, Pink, Prism, and Negative variations from 2017 Topps Chrome. These can significantly increase the card’s value.

How Can I Determine a Card’s Condition and Value?

The card’s condition greatly affects its value. Look for cards in mint condition (graded 9 or 10 by professional grading services like PSA or BGS). You can check online marketplaces or consult price guides to assess their current values.

What Are Some Key Considerations When Investing in Aaron Judge Rookie Cards?

When investing in Aaron Judge rookie cards, consider his performance, potential, and market trends. Look for rare parallels and high-quality, graded cards. Be patient and stay updated on the baseball season.

Are Autographed Rookie Cards More Valuable?

Yes, autographed rookie cards are generally more valuable due to their rarity and the added value of the player’s signature. Aaron Judge’s autographed rookie cards are highly sought after by collectors.

Can Rookie Cards Be a Good Investment?

Yes, rookie cards can be a good investment, especially for standout players like Aaron Judge. They have the potential to increase in value over time, making them attractive to collectors and investors.

Where Can I Buy Aaron Judge Rookie Cards?

You can buy Aaron Judge rookie cards from reputable sports card shops, online marketplaces (eBay, COMC, etc.), card shows, and auctions. Ensure you’re purchasing from trusted sources and verify the card’s authenticity.

Please note that card values and market trends can change, so it’s essential to do your research and stay informed when collecting or investing in rookie cards.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *