Hello everyone, it’s Matt here from Graded Card Investor Today, I’m excited to share with you the latest compilation of the most valuable baseball rookie cards from the 1960s, perfect for those considering investment opportunities.
While legends like Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Hank Aaron, and Roberto Clemente are undoubtedly valuable, this list will primarily spotlight rookie cards with significant investment potential.
For a detailed year-by-year analysis and to discover the top players from each year, make sure to check out our other articles or visit the baseball card page on our website.
Now, without any further ado, let’s dive into this exciting list!
1962 Topps Joe Torre RC #218
- Grade: PSA 8
- Auction House: Robert Edward Auctions
- Sale Date: June 2023
- Sale Price: $1,080
➡️ Check The Value Of This 1962 Topps Joe Torre Rookie Card On eBay
Market Analysis: 1962 Topps Joe Torre RC #218
- Supply: PSA has graded 1,539 of the 1962 Topps Joe Torre rookie cards with 1 grading gem mint 10, 20 mint 9, 120 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
- PSA 8 Value:
- PSA 8 sold by Robert Edward Auctions inJune 2023 for $1,080
- PSA 7 Value:
- PSA 7 sold by PWCC Auctions in September 2023 for $252
🔥 The Best 1962 Topps Baseball Cards – Highest Selling Prices
1966 Topps Don Sutton RC #288
- Grade: PSA 9
- Auction House: eBay
- Sale Date: November 2023
- Sale Price: $1,655
➡️ Check The Value Of The 1966 Topps Don Sutton Rookie Card On eBay
Market Analysis: 1966 Topps Don Sutton Rookie Card #288
- Supply: PSA has graded 2,729 of the 1966 Topps Don Sutton rookie cards with 4 grading gem mint 10, 53 mint 9, 293 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
- PSA 9 Value:
- PSA 9 sold on eBay in November 2023 for $1,655
- PSA 8 Value:
- PSA 8 sold on eBay in November 2023 for $427
🔥 The Best 1966 Topps Baseball Cards – Highest Selling Prices
1966 Topps Fergie Jenkins RC #254
- Grade: PSA 9
- Auction House: PWCC Auctions
- Sale Date: January 2024
- Sale Price: $1,860
➡️ Check The Value Of The 1966 Topps Fergie Jenkins Rookie Card On eBay
Market Analysis: 1966 Topps Fergie Jenkins Rookie Card #288
- Supply: PSA has graded 3,027 of the 1966 Topps Fergie Jenkins rookie cards with 7 grading gem mint 10, 70 mint 9, 382 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
- PSA 9 Value:
- PSA 9 sold by PWCC Auctions in January 2024 for $1,860
- PSA 8 Value:
- PSA 8 sold on eBay in October 2023 for $405
🔥 The Best 1966 Topps Baseball Cards – Highest Selling Prices
1965 Topps Steve Carlton RC #477
- Grade: PSA 9
- Auction House: eBay
- Sale Date: November 2023
- Sale Price: $2,750
➡️ Check The Value Of This 1965 Topps Steve Carlton Rookie Card On eBay
Market Analysis: 1965 Topps Steve Carlton Rookie Card #477
- Supply: PSA has graded 7,263 of the 1965 Topps Steve Carlton rookie cards with 7 grading gem mint 10, 227 mint 9, 1,165 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
- PSA 9 Value:
- PSA 9 sold on eBay in November 2023 for $2,750
- PSA 8 Value:
- PSA 8 sold on eBay in November 2023 for $811
🔥 The Best 1965 Topps Baseball Cards – Highest Selling Prices
1965 Topps Tony Perez RC #581
- Grade: PSA 9
- Auction House: Heritage Auctions
- Sale Date: September 2022
- Sale Price: $3,120
➡️ Check The Value Of The 1965 Topps Tony Perez Rookie Card On eBay
Market Analysis: 1965 Topps Tony Perez Rookie Card #581
- Supply: PSA has graded 3,525 of the 1965 Topps Tony Perez rookie cards with 4 grading gem mint 10, 98 mint 9, 609 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
- PSA 9 Value:
- PSA 9 sold by Heritage Auctions in September 2022 for $3,120
- PSA 8 Value:
🔥 The Best 1965 Topps Baseball Cards – Highest Selling Prices
1965 Topps Joe Morgan RC #16
- Grade: PSA 9
- Auction House: eBay
- Sale Date: November 2023
- Sale Price: $3,564
➡️ Check The Value Of This 1965 Topps Joe Morgan Rookie Card On eBay
Market Analysis: 1965 Topps Joe Morgan Rookie Card #16
- Supply: PSA has graded 4,913 of the 1965 Topps Joe Morgan rookie cards with 2 grading gem mint 10, 85 mint 9, 542 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
- PSA 9 Value:
- PSA 9 sold on eBay in November 2023 for $3,564
- PSA 8 Value:
- PSA 8 sold on eBay in December 2023 for $1,120
🔥 The Best 1965 Topps Baseball Cards – Highest Selling Prices
1968 Topps Johnny Bench RC #247
- Grade: PSA 9
- Auction House: eBay
- Sale Date: January 2024
- Sale Price: $4,556
➡️ Check The Value Of This 1968 Topps Johnny Bench Rookie Card On eBay
Market Analysis: 1968 Topps Johnny Bench Rookie Card #247
Supply: PSA has graded 3,028 of the 1968 Topps Johnny Bench rookie cards with 22 grading gem mint 10, 47 mint 9, 502 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
- PSA 9 Value:
- PSA 8 Value:
- PSA 8 sold on eBay in December 2023 for $1,286
🔥 The Best 1968 Topps Baseball Cards – Highest Selling Prices
1966 Topps Jim Palmer RC #126
- Grade: PSA 9
- Auction House: eBay
- Sale Date: October 2023
- Sale Price: $4,560
➡️ Check The Value Of The 1966 Topps Jim Palmer Rookie Card On eBay
Market Analysis: 1966 Topps Jim Palmer Rookie Card #126
- Supply: PSA has graded 5,057 of the 1966 Topps Jim Palmer rookie cards with none grading gem mint 10, 82 mint 9, 526 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
- PSA 9 Value:
- PSA 9 sold by PWCC Auctions in December 2023 for $4,560
- PSA 8 Value:
- PSA 8 sold on eBay in November 2023 for $814
🔥 The Best 1966 Topps Baseball Cards – Highest Selling Prices
1963 Topps Willie Stargell RC #553
- Grade: PSA 9
- Auction House: PWCC Auctions
- Sale Date: August 2023
- Sale Price: $12,600
⚾️ Check the Value of the Willie Stargell Rookie Card on eBay Now!
Market Analysis: 1963 Topps Willie Stargell Rookie Card #553
- Supply: PSA has graded 6,151 of the 1963 Topps Willie Stargell rookies with 2 grading gem mint 10, 34 mint 9, 393 near mint to mint 8.
- Mint 9 Value:
- PSA 9 sold by PWCC Auctions in June 2023 for $12,600
- PSA 8 Value:
- PSA 8 sold on eBay in December 2023 for $1,175
🔥 The Best 1963 Topps Baseball Cards – Highest Selling Prices
1967 Topps Rod Carew RC #569
- Grade: PSA 9
- Auction House: Heritage Auctions
- Sale Date: November 2023
- Sale Price: $15,000
➡️ Check Values Of The 1967 Topps Rod Carew Rookie Card On eBay
Market Analysis: 1967 Topps Rod Carew Rookie Card #569
Supply: PSA has graded 3,813 of the 1967 Topps Rod Carew rookie cards with 1 grading gem mint 10, 62 mint 9, 441 NM-MT 8 and the remaining Nm 7 or less.
- PSA 9 Value:
- PSA 8 Value:
- PSA 8 sold on eBay in November 2023 for $2,424
🔥 The Best 1967 Topps Baseball Cards – Highest Selling Prices
1967 Topps Tom Seaver RC #581
- Grade: PSA 9
- Auction House: Heritage Auctions
- Sale Date: November 2023
- Sale Price: $15,600
➡️ Check Values Of The 1967 Topps Tom Seaver Rookie Card On eBay
Market Analysis: 1967 Topps Tom Seaver Rookie Card #581
Supply: PSA has graded 3,949 of the 1967 Topps Tom Seaver rookie cards with 3 grading gem mint 10, 95 mint 9, 613 NM-MT 8 and the remaining Nm 7 or less.
- PSA 9 Value:
- PSA 8 Value:
- PSA 8 sold on eBay in November 2023 for $3,618
🔥 The Best 1967 Topps Baseball Cards – Highest Selling Prices
1962 Topps Lou Brock RC #387
- Grade: PSA 9
- Auction House: PWCC Auctions
- Sale Date: October 2022
- Sale Price: $19,200
➡️ Check The Value Of This 1962 Topps Lou Brock Rookie Card On eBay
Market Analysis: 1962 Topps Lou Brock RC #387
- Supply: PSA has graded 4,574 of the 1962 Topps Lou Brock rookie cards with 2 grading gem mint 10, 31 mint 9, 265 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
- PSA 9 Value:
- PSA 8 Value:
- PSA 8 sold on eBay in November 2023 for $2,114
🔥 The Best 1962 Topps Baseball Cards – Highest Selling Prices
1960 Topps Jim Kaat RC #136
- Grade: PSA 9
- Auction House: Memory Lane, Inc.
- Sale Date: January 2024
- Sale Price: $3,705
➡️ Check The Value Of The 1960 Topps Jim Kaat Rookie Card On eBay
Market Analysis: 1960 Topps Jim Kaat Rookie Card #136
Supply: PSA has graded 427 of the 1960 Topps Jim Kaat rookie cards with 2 grading gem mint 10, 42 mint 9, 176 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
- PSA 9 Value:
- PSA 9 sold by Memory Lane, Inc. in January 2024 for $3,705
- PSA 8 Value:
- PSA 8 sold on eBay in November 2023 for $755
🔥 The Best 1960 Topps Baseball Cards – Highest Selling Prices
1960 Topps Willie McCovey RC #316
- Grade: PSA 9
- Auction House: eBay
- Sale Date: November 2023
- Sale Price: $19,644
➡️ Check The Value Of The 1960 Topps Willie McCovey Rookie Card On eBay
Market Analysis: 1960 Topps Willie McCovey Rookie Card #316
Supply: PSA has graded 5,982 of the 1960 Topps Willie McCovey rookie cards with none grading gem mint 10, 30 mint 9, 295 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
- PSA 9 Value:
- PSA 8 Value:
🔥 The Best 1960 Topps Baseball Cards – Highest Selling Prices
1960 Topps Carl Yastrzemski RC #148
- Grade: PSA 9
- Auction House: PWCC Auctions
- Sale Date: October 2023
- Sale Price: $20,700
➡️ Check The Value Of The 1960 Topps Carl Yastrzemski Rookie Card On eBay
Market Analysis: 1960 Topps Carl Yastrzemski Rookie Card #148
Supply: PSA has graded 10,502 of the 1960 Topps Carl Yastrzemski rookie cards with 1 grading gem mint 10, 44 mint 9, 207 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
- PSA 9 Value:
- PSA 9 sold by PWCC Auctions in October 2023 for $20,700
- PSA 8 Value:
- PSA 8 sold on eBay in December 2023 for $1,856
- PSA 7 Value:
- PSA 7 sold by PWCC Auctions in October 2023 for $720
🔥 Top 15 Best Carl Yastrzemski Baseball Cards with Recent Sales
1969 Topps Reggie Jackson RC #260
- Grade: PSA 9
- Auction House: Memory Lane, Inc.
- Sale Date: May 2022
- Sale Price: $68,760
➡️ Check The Value Of The 1969 Topps Reggie Jackson Rookie Card On eBay
Market Analysis: 1969 Topps Reggie Jackson Rookie Card #260
Supply: PSA has graded 10,711 of the 1969 Topps Reggie Jackson rookie cards with 1 grading gem mint 10, 41 grading mint 9, 573 NM-MT 8 and the remaining Nm 7 or less.
1968 Topps Nolan Ryan RC #177
- Grade: PSA 9
- Auction House: Heritage Auctions
- Sale Date: August 2023
- Sale Price: $81,000
➡️ Check The Value Of This 1968 Topps Nolan Ryan RC On eBay
Market Analysis: 1968 Topps Nolan Ryan RC #177
Supply: PSA has graded 3,028 of the 1968 Topps Nolan Ryan rookie cards with 22 grading gem mint 10, 47 mint 9, 502 NM-MT 8 and the remaining NM 7 or less.
- PSA 9 Value:
- PSA 8 Value:
1963 Topps Pete Rose RC #537
- Grade: PSA 9
- Auction House: Heritage Auctions
- Sale Date: August 2023
- Sale Price: $84,000
➡️ Shop The 1963 Topps Pete Rose Rookie Card on eBay Now!
Market Analysis: 1963 Topps Pete Rose Rookie Card #537
- Supply: PSA has graded 6,151 of the 1963 Topps Pete Rose rookies with 1 grading gem mint 10, 30 mint 9, 424 near mint to mint 8.
- Mint 9 Value:
- PSA 8 Value:
Overview: This ’63 Topps Pete Rose rookie card is a standout investment in the world of high-grade assets. Rose, one of the greatest players not in the Hall of Fame, is known for his all-time hit record and his ban from baseball due to gambling allegations.
This rare, high-quality rookie card of Rose, who ranks alongside greats like Reggie Jackson and Nolan Ryan, is not just a collectible but an investment piece with promising future value. Despite his absence from the Hall of Fame, Rose’s 4,256 hits and lasting fame make his 1963 Topps Rookie card a coveted and significant asset in any collection.
Conclusion
If you’re diving into the world of baseball card investments from the 1960s, don’t miss the top cards listed above. These gems stand out as the most valuable from the 1960s, primarily because they are the first printed cards of many players – making them coveted rookie cards. Their rarity and significance in baseball history ignite fierce competition among collectors, especially for high-graded examples.
Remember, a card doesn’t have to be in gem mint condition to be a worthy investment. PSA 8s and 9s can also offer great value. Keep an eye on PSA’s population reports to gauge the rarity of each rookie card. Regularly monitoring past eBay auctions can provide insights into market trends – are the prices fluctuating up or down?
I’m eager to hear from you in the comments below. Which baseball cards from the 60s do you find most valuable and collectible? Share your insights or any intriguing stories you have about these timeless treasures!
From a young age, Matt dove deep into sports card valuation, turning to esteemed price guides like Beckett and Tuff Stuff. Eventually he extended to Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, and Yu-Gi-Oh!. With a vision to sustain and nurture the hobby he loved, Matt established the ‘Graded Card Investor’ YouTube channel and website. He aims to foster a healthy community and offer invaluable insights to those entering the world of sports cards and TCGs. His depth of understanding, from the card market’s 2020 pinnacle to its 1990s valleys, is consistently fortified by meticulous research.
I have a 1963 rookie stars and 1964 there identical I’ve never seen a 64 that looks like the 63 with same 4 people on it has anyone else