8 Best Baseball Cards to Collect & Buy Now! 2023

#1. Shohei Ohtani

Read More: Top 15 Shohei Ohtani Rookie Cards
Baseball-Reference: Shohei Ohtani

Shohei Ohtani: The Two-Way Dynamo

Alright, folks, we’ve got to talk about Shohei Ohtani. This guy is not your run-of-the-mill ballplayer. No, sir. He’s a rare breed, a two-way superstar who can both pitch and hit like a champ. Let me give you the lowdown on this incredible talent.

The Japanese Whiz Kid

Hailing from Japan, Ohtani made his grand entrance into Major League Baseball (MLB) with the Los Angeles Angels back in 2018. From the get-go, he had folks buzzing with excitement because he’s not your typical player.

Pitching Wizardry

Now, let’s start with his pitching, shall we? Ohtani’s got an arm that can fling fastballs like lightning and some breaking balls that can leave batters scratching their heads. When he takes the mound, he’s like a maestro conducting a symphony of strikeouts. The dude knows how to control the game.

A Beast at the Plate

But hold onto your seats because that’s not all. Ohtani’s got a mean swing too. When he steps up to bat, you can feel the energy in the stadium. He’s got the power to smack those balls out of the park and the finesse to make precise hits when it counts the most.

Injury Hurdles

Now, let’s address the elephant in the room—his injuries. Ohtani’s had to battle through some tough times, and we’ve missed seeing him in action. But you know what? This guy’s got heart. He’s been working his tail off to get back in the game, and we can’t wait to see him back on the field.

A Glorious Future

Shohei Ohtani’s story is far from over. We’re just scratching the surface of what this baseball wizard can do. The guy’s already achieved some incredible stuff that most players only dream about. Whether he’s on the mound or in the batter’s box, Ohtani’s got this uncanny ability to keep us all glued to our seats.

The future? Well, my friends, it’s looking brighter than a home run under stadium lights. Shohei Ohtani’s got that special something, that X-factor that sets him apart. We’re in for a wild ride, and I, for one, can’t wait to see where this baseball maverick takes us next.

#2. Mike Trout

Read More: Top 15 Mike Trout Rookie Cards
Baseball-Reference: Mike Trout

Mike Trout: The Ultimate Baseball Card Collectible

According to ESPN, “Mike Trout is on pace for the greatest season in MLB history.” MLB.com echoes this sentiment, stating that “Still just 27 and only in his seventh full Major League season, Trout is essentially already a Hall of Famer.” With such accolades, it’s no surprise that Mike Trout tops the list of the best baseball cards to collect. Let’s delve into his background and understand why.

Trout’s Background: A Natural Talent

Baseball is in Mike Trout’s DNA. His father played baseball for the University of Delaware and was drafted by the Minnesota Twins in 1983. Although his father’s career was cut short due to injury, one look at Mike is enough to see that exceptional athleticism runs in the Trout family.

Statistical Excellence: A Five-Tool Player

Trout’s statistics are nothing short of remarkable. With 37 home runs, 74 RBIs, a .316 batting average, and a lifetime WAR (Wins Above Replacement) of 54, Trout truly embodies the concept of a five-tool player. Beyond his impressive averages, Trout showcases power hitting, exceptional base running, defensive prowess, and the ability to make clutch plays. His achievements throughout the league underscore his excellence.

Awards and Honors: Rookie of the Year to MVP

Mike Trout received the Rookie of the Year (ROY) Award in 2012, and he’s continued to elevate his game ever since. With seven All-Star selections and two MVP Awards, Trout’s presence on the field goes beyond just being an all-star; he is a game-changer.

Setting Records: Youthful Accomplishments

Trout’s accomplishments at a young age are nothing short of historic. He became the youngest player to achieve 100 home runs and 100 stolen bases. In the 2015 MLB All-Star Game, Trout achieved another milestone by becoming the fourth player to start an All-Star Game with a home run. While Trout’s WAR is exceptional, it’s noteworthy that he excels in almost every aspect of the game, from hitting and getting on base to his defensive skills.

The Hall of Fame Trajectory: A True Baseball Great

It’s challenging to pinpoint a single statistic or skill that defines Trout’s potential Hall of Fame career. His all-around abilities make him a threat both at the plate and in the field. As long as he maintains his stellar performance, Mike Trout is poised to follow in the footsteps of baseball legends.

Collecting Mike Trout: A Valuable Investment

For numerous reasons, Mike Trout stands out as one of the best baseball cards to collect in 2019. Beyond his on-field prowess, he enjoys immense popularity among fans and collectors. While acquiring some of his most sought-after rookie cards can be a substantial investment, consider looking for his 2009 Donruss Elite rookies. These cards are relatively more affordable while retaining their collectible appeal, ensuring that every collector, regardless of budget, can have a piece of the Trout legacy.

#3. Ronald Acuña Jr.

Read More: Top 10 Ronald Acuna Jr. Rookie Cards
Baseball-Reference: Ronald Acuna Jr.

Ronald Acuña Jr.: A Rising Star Worth Collecting

Ronald Acuña Jr. has rapidly emerged as one of the most promising prospects in the league. Baseball America recognized his immense potential by ranking him as the number 1 prospect heading into the 2018 season. His recent contract extension with the Braves has sparked a frenzy among collectors eager to acquire his best rookie cards. Let’s delve into why Ronald Acuña Jr. is a must-have for baseball card collectors.

A $100 Million Milestone

On April 2, 2019, Ronald Acuña Jr. and the Braves made history by agreeing to an eight-year contract valued at an astonishing $100 million. This landmark deal included team options for the 2027 and 2028 seasons. What makes this feat even more remarkable is that, at just 21 years old, Acuña became the youngest player in MLB history to sign a contract worth at least $100 million.

A Prolific Start

Acuña wasted no time in showcasing his enormous talent. By June 2019, he had garnered attention for his remarkable performance on the field. He was not only named a starting outfielder for the National League in the 2019 Major League Baseball All-Star Game but was also invited to participate in that year’s Home Run Derby.

Collecting Ronald Acuña Jr.

For collectors seeking the best Ronald Acuña Jr. baseball cards, the focus should be on the 2017 and 2018 editions. His 2017 Bowman Chrome rookie autograph refractors are highly coveted items, as are the 2018 Topps Update parallels. In particular, the Mother’s Day Pink parallel, limited to only 50 copies, is a standout choice. However, since Acuña’s career is still in its early stages, any of his rookie cards could prove to be a valuable investment.

Acuña’s combination of youthful talent, historic contract, and potential for greatness on the field make him a standout choice for collectors looking to secure an asset with the potential to appreciate significantly in value.

#4. Mookie Betts

Read More: Best Mookie Betts Rookie Cards to Buy Now!
Baseball-Reference: Mookie Betts

Mookie Betts: A Rising Star to Collect

The 2014 Bowman Chrome Mookie Betts Rookie Card stands as a shining star in the world of baseball card collecting. Let’s explore why this card ranks high among the top Mookie Betts rookie cards in 2019.

A Versatile Dynamo

Mookie Betts has swiftly emerged as one of baseball’s most dynamic and versatile players. His incredible prowess on both sides of the ball makes him a standout in today’s game. Betts consistently delivers stellar performances, making his cards highly sought after by collectors.

Highlights of Excellence

Mookie Betts’s accomplishments on the field have solidified his reputation as a premier player. His 2018 season with the Boston Red Sox was nothing short of spectacular. Betts achieved a remarkable .346 batting average, slugged 32 home runs, and drove in 80 runs. He also displayed incredible defensive skills, earning him a Gold Glove Award. Betts’s achievements culminated in winning the American League Most Valuable Player (MVP) title, a testament to his impact on the game.

Stealing the Show

Betts is not just a hitting maestro; he possesses remarkable speed on the basepaths. His ability to steal bases consistently adds an exciting dimension to his game. Collectors are not only interested in his bat but also in the electrifying moments he creates on the diamond.

A Defensive Marvel

Betts’s fielding prowess is a thing of beauty. His remarkable agility, lightning-quick reflexes, and precise throws make him one of the best outfielders in the game. His defensive excellence adds tremendous value to his cards, as collectors admire his all-around skills.

Future Promise

At a relatively young age, Mookie Betts has already achieved a great deal in his career. However, the best may be yet to come. Betts’s potential for further growth and future accolades make his rookie cards an exciting investment for collectors.

Collecting Mookie Betts

For collectors seeking the best baseball cards in 2019, Mookie Betts presents a compelling choice. His 2014 Bowman Chrome rookie cards are highly regarded and offer a glimpse into his promising career. Collectors can explore various parallels, including refractors, to add depth to their collections.

As Mookie Betts continues to shine on the baseball stage, his rookie cards remain a prized possession for collectors who appreciate the artistry and skill he brings to the game.

#5. Bryce Harper

Read More: Best Bryce Harpers Rookie Cards to Buy Now!
Baseball-Reference: Bryce Harper

Bryce Harper: A Force to Collect

The 2012 Bowman Chrome Bryce Harper Rookie Card is a gem worth coveting. Let’s delve into why this card ranks high on the list of top Bryce Harper rookie cards in 2019.

A Season of Highlights

Bryce Harper secures the second spot on my list of the best baseball cards to collect in 2019. While his 2018 season with the Washington Nationals showcased his prowess with 34 home runs, it might not have been a season for the history books. However, Harper did shine brilliantly in the 2018 Home Run Derby, edging out his competition with a score of 19-18.

Overcoming Challenges

It’s worth noting that Harper has faced his fair share of challenges, including injuries and the unpredictable nature of the sport. His future team choices have been a subject of intense speculation, adding to the intrigue surrounding his career.

While Harper may not openly discuss these pressures, it’s evident that something hasn’t quite clicked in the past couple of seasons. To assess Harper’s potential Hall of Fame candidacy, we must look beyond recent performances and consider his entire baseball career.

A Born Ballplayer

Bryce Harper’s journey in baseball began early. He joined his youth travel team at the tender age of 7, and by the time he was 12, he was smashing balls over 250-foot fences. His prodigious talent caught the attention of Sports Illustrated, which hailed him as “Baseball’s Chosen One.” Harper’s unanimous Rookie of the Year (ROY) win in 2012 was just the beginning.

In 2015, he posted impressive statistics, including a .330 batting average, .460 on-base percentage, and .649 slugging percentage. He led the National League in on-base performance and clinched an MVP title.

The Future Awaits

As Harper’s contract with the Nationals concluded, the baseball world eagerly anticipates his next move, likely for a substantial sum.

Collecting Bryce Harper

For collectors seeking the best baseball cards in 2019, Bryce Harper is a compelling choice. While some of his rookies, like Trout’s, command high prices, there are more affordable options. One notable card is the 2011 Bowman Chrome Superfractor rookie autograph, graded BGS 9.5, currently listed on eBay for a staggering $499,999.99, with 562 eBay sellers keeping a close watch.

If half a million dollars isn’t within your budget, consider exploring his Bowman’s Best and Topps Heritage rookies. These options are far more accessible and equally collectible.

Bryce Harper’s journey in baseball, marked by impressive achievements and potential for future greatness, makes his rookie cards a valuable addition to any collection.

#6. Clayton Kershaw

Clayton Kershaw: A Left-Handed Legend

Let’s set the record straight from the start: Clayton Kershaw is a left-handed pitcher, and there’s a common belief that southpaws face an uphill battle when it comes to making it into the Hall of Fame. But take a look at Sandy Koufax, a Hall of Fame legend who was also a lefty. Kershaw’s stats, however, speak volumes for his potential Hall of Fame candidacy.

Ace of the Dodgers

At the tender age of 23, Kershaw emerged as the ace of the Los Angeles Dodgers, capturing the coveted pitching Triple Crown by leading the league in wins, strikeouts, and earned run average (ERA). He notched an impressive 21 wins and sent 248 batters back to the dugout. His remarkable performance earned him not only the Cy Young Award but also the admiration of baseball fans worldwide.

A Picasso on the Mound

Kershaw’s pitching style is often likened to a work of art, with his impeccable command of the strike zone and a vast repertoire of pitches. When he made his World Series debut in 2017, it was akin to a masterpiece on the baseball diamond. He is no stranger to dominance and has consistently been considered one of the league’s best.

A Career Steeped in Excellence

Despite the recent injuries that have temporarily kept Kershaw off the field, he remains a shining example of a performance pitcher. His impressive Wins Above Replacement (WAR) stands at 54.8, a testament to his exceptional contributions to his team’s success.

A Promising Path to Immortality

While Kershaw may be nursing injuries at the moment, there’s little doubt that he will bounce back. With potentially another decade of excellence ahead of him, Clayton Kershaw stands a strong chance of achieving baseball immortality in Cooperstown.

So, let’s not underestimate the power of this left-handed legend. Clayton Kershaw’s journey in baseball is far from over, and his legacy is still being written.

#7. Aaron Judge

Read More: Top 15 Aaron Judge Rookie Cards
Baseball-Reference: Aaron Judge

Aaron Judge: The Rise and Fall of the 2013 Bowman Chrome Rookie Card

Aaron Judge’s baseball cards from 2013 through 2019 have been some of the most sought-after collectibles in the baseball card market. However, their prices have experienced both highs and lows. This is largely due to Judge’s dominating presence at the plate, which has left collectors and investors debating whether he could become the next home run king.

Despite his impressive performance and record-breaking achievements in New York and MLB, the fervor among collectors for investing in this gentle giant has cooled off significantly. Let’s delve into the rollercoaster ride of the 2013 Bowman Chrome rookie base card.

The Rise of the 2013 Bowman Chrome Rookie Card

Since 2013, a substantial number of the 2013 Bowman Chrome base Aaron Judge rookie cards have been sold in PSA cases. However, the first recorded auction of one of these cards took place in May 2017 and concluded with an astonishing final bid of $304.

Why did the price soar to such heights?

In 2017, Judge finished the season with a batting average of .284, an impressive 52 home runs, and 114 RBIs. He led the American League in home runs, runs scored (with 128), and walks (setting a major-league rookie record with 127).

Additionally, he ranked second in the league in RBIs. It’s worth noting that he also set an MLB record with 208 strikeouts, surpassing the previous Yankees record held by Curtis Granderson in 2012 and a rookie record established by Kris Bryant in 2015.

The Fall

Today, the base 2013 Bowman Chrome card, even in PSA 10 gem mint condition, is selling for under $80 each. This dramatic drop in price can be attributed, in part, to collectors shifting their interest toward other rising stars like Bellinger and Trout.

It’s unlikely that Judge’s minor wrist fracture and leg strain are the sole reasons behind this price decline. Despite a somewhat less spectacular 2019 season, Judge has undoubtedly etched his name into MLB history. As such, he should not be overlooked when considering investments in sports cards.

#8. Cody Bellinger

Cody Bellinger: A Rising Star in Major League Baseball

Baseball-Reference: Cody Bellinger

Cody Bellinger has emerged as one of the fastest-rising stars in Major League Baseball. His journey began when the Los Angeles Dodgers signed him in 2013. He made his professional debut with the Arizona League Dodgers, where he started with a .210 batting average and a notable 46 strikeouts in just 47 games. Despite his challenging start, scouts recognized the potential in this promising hitter.

Bellinger’s path to the big leagues included stops with several teams, including the Ogden Raptors, Rancho Cucamonga Quakes, Tulsa Drillers, Glendale Desert Dogs, and the Oklahoma City Dodgers. Finally, on April 25, 2017, Bellinger got his chance to shine in the majors.

2017 National League Rookie of the Year

In his debut season in the majors, Bellinger played in 132 games, boasting a .267 batting average, 39 home runs, and 97 RBIs. His impressive performance earned him the title of Sporting News NL Rookie of the Year. Bellinger’s post-season journey was equally noteworthy, as he played in all 15 Dodgers games, contributing with a .219 batting average, three home runs, and nine RBIs.

However, he also set the record for the most strikeouts in a single postseason with 29, with 17 of those coming in the World Series alone. Despite this, he was unanimously voted as the National League Rookie of the Year.

2019 Season: Setting Records Ablaze

Bellinger’s 2019 season was nothing short of spectacular. On April 26, he hit his 13th home run, making him the first player in MLB history to amass 88 total bases before May, surpassing the previous record held by Chase Utley. His remarkable 97 total bases, 37 RBIs, 47 hits, 14 home runs, and 32 runs scored all established new Major League records for accomplishments before May 1.

On August 2nd, Bellinger reached a significant milestone by hitting his 100th career home run, achieved off Eric Lauer of the San Diego Padres. In doing so, he became the fastest player in Dodgers history to reach this mark, accomplishing it in his 401st game, surpassing Mike Piazza’s record of 422 games. On August 15, at the young age of 24, he became the youngest player in Dodgers history to achieve 40 home runs in a single season.

Collecting Cody Bellinger: The Thrill of the Hunt

For collectors, Cody Bellinger’s baseball cards are prized possessions. Among the most sought-after are his 2015 Bowman Chrome refractor rookie autographs, which come in various colored parallels with different print runs. These include the elusive one-of-one Superfractor, Red refractor (/5), Orange (/25), Gold (/50), Green (/99), and Blue (/150).

His 2017 Topps Chrome rookie autographs are equally coveted, similar to the Bowman Chrome counterparts. Given that Bellinger’s MLB career started in 2017, his card market is still relatively fresh, offering collectors the opportunity to acquire short-printed rookies at reasonable prices compared to established players like Trout and Harper.

#9. Mike Stanton

Mike Stanton: A Hall of Fame Hopeful

In a league filled with big hitters, one player stands out from the crowd, and he’s a strong contender for the Hall of Fame. Mike Stanton, known for his incredible power at the plate, has been making waves in the baseball card collecting world, making him third on our list of the best baseball cards to collect in 2019.

A Rocky Start

It’s worth noting that even the most impressive players can have their rough patches. Stanton’s 2018 season got off to a challenging start, marked by a streak of being the first player in two games without a hit and amassing five strikeouts. An interesting tidbit is that ESPN pointed out Stanton had more strikeouts in Week 16 of 2017 than Joe DiMaggio had throughout the entire year of 1941.

Adding to his adversity, Stanton faced a major setback when he took an 88 MPH fastball to the face. His remarkable return to the game after such a severe injury is a testament to his resilience. Few players can bounce back from such a traumatic incident, showcasing Stanton’s exceptional determination.

Hall of Fame Aspirations

Does Stanton’s challenging season mean he’s not a worthy candidate for the Hall of Fame? Not at all. Transitioning to a new team can have a significant impact on a ballplayer’s performance. One subpar season shouldn’t overshadow the potential of one of baseball’s most commanding hitters. Moreover, as the former Marlins’ all-time home run leader, Stanton is displaying promise and continues to demonstrate his abilities.

The Power-Hitting Machine

Mike Stanton is undoubtedly a power-hitting sensation. He holds the record for the hardest-hit ball since the inception of Statcast, clocking in at an impressive 121.7 MPH. This slugger consistently sends baseballs flying out of the park, making it seem effortless. In 2017, Stanton came just one home run short of hitting 60 homers, further solidifying his reputation as a home run machine.

Consistency and Investment

What sets Stanton apart is not just his power but also his remarkable consistency. He consistently makes hard contact with the ball, boasting an impressive 50% hard contact rate, a feat unmatched by any other player in baseball. It’s no surprise that the New York Yankees invested a whopping $265 million in Stanton, recognizing his incredible talent and potential.

As Mike Stanton’s baseball cards continue to gain value, collectors are keeping a close eye on this Hall of Fame hopeful, making him a must-have addition to any baseball card collection in 2019.

Conclusion

Collecting baseball cards can be an exciting and potentially rewarding venture, but it’s crucial to approach it with diligence and strategy. Here are some key takeaways to keep in mind:

1. Do Your Research: Before diving into the world of baseball card collecting, take the time to research and gather information. Websites like www.baseball-reference.com can provide a wealth of statistics and insights to help you make informed decisions about which players to collect.

2. Diversify Your Collection: It’s wise to diversify your collection rather than putting all your focus on one player. By spreading your investments across multiple players, you can mitigate the risk of a single player’s performance affecting your entire collection. Consider buying cards from various players as their careers progress.

3. Stay Off the Bandwagon: Card prices often surge when players have breakout seasons or exceptional stats. Instead of following the crowd and buying during these high-demand periods, consider looking for opportunities when the market is less active. For example, if a player like Kershaw is having a stellar year but Harper isn’t, it might be a good time to acquire some more affordable Harper rookies. Don’t always chase the highest prices; look for players who are performing well but may be flying under the radar.

Remember, successful baseball card collecting isn’t just about the players with the highest prices; it’s about identifying potential breakout stars and making well-informed choices. Best of luck with your collecting journey, and feel free to ask any questions you may have below.