Top 20 Hank Aaron Baseball Cards with Recent Prices

Hey guys, Matt here with  Graded Card Investor and today I’m listing of the top 15 highest-selling and recently sold Hank Aaron baseball cards. Now, for the most part these cards are all graded by PSA and are in either NM-MT 8 or Mint 9 condition so the prices are higher than raw examples.

This list goes in order from the year and not the value so pay attention to the sales prices and PSA population (supply). Make sure to check back for updates and comment at the bottom what Hank Aaron baseball card you think should be on the list.

Without any further ado, let’s jump into this list! I posted the Youtube video below for those of you that prefer the video format.

Top 20 Most Valuable Hank Aaron Baseball Cards (Based on Recent Sales)

Here is the full ranked list from the video, including the sale price, grade, and key population report data.

#20: 1959 Topps #380 (PSA 7)

• Sold For: $710
• Population: 596 PSA 7s (7,574 total submitted)

#19: 1967 Topps #250 (PSA 8)

• Sold For: $913
• Population: 675 PSA 8s (5,777 total submitted)

#18: 1964 Topps #300 (PSA 8)

• Sold For: $1,111
• Population: 457 PSA 8s (5,318 total submitted)

#17: 1971 Topps #400 (PSA 8)

• Sold For: $1,147
• Population: 592 PSA 8s (5,630 total submitted)

#16: 1969 Topps #100 (PSA 8)

• Sold For: $1,176
• Population: 481 PSA 8s (7,100 total submitted)

#15: 1958 Topps #30 (White Name Variation) (PSA 7)

• Sold For: $1,300
• Population: 425 PSA 7s (5,737 total submitted)

#14: 1965 Topps #170 (PSA 8)

• Sold For: $1,435
• Population: 639 PSA 8s (6,696 total submitted)

#13: 1973 Topps #100 (PSA 9)

• Sold For: $1,450
• Population: 221 PSA 9s (6,523 total submitted)

#12: 1955 Bowman #179 (PSA 7)

• Sold For: $1,695
• Population: 247 PSA 7s (3,724 total submitted)

#11: 1970 Topps All-Star #462 (PSA 9)

• Sold For: $2,437
• Population: Only 21 PSA 9s (1,660 total submitted)

#10: 1968 Topps #110 (PSA 9)

• Sold For: $2,750
• Population: 174 PSA 9s (6,459 total submitted)

#9: 1955 Topps #47 (PSA 7)

• Sold For: $2,900
• Population: 560 PSA 7s (7,872 total submitted)

#8: 1959 Topps All-Star #561 (PSA 9)

• Sold For: $3,261
• Population: Only 23 PSA 9s (2,563 total submitted)

#7: 1962 Topps #320 (PSA 8)

• Sold For: $3,383
• Population: 225 PSA 8s (4,477 total submitted)

#6: 1966 Topps #500 (PSA 8.5)

• Sold For: $3,460
• Population: Only 9 PSA 8.5s (3,344 total submitted)

#5: 1972 Topps #299 (PSA 9)

• Sold For: $3,650
• Population: Only 16 PSA 9s (5,316 total submitted)

#4: 1957 Topps #20 (PSA 8)

• Sold For: $3,649
• Population: 322 PSA 8s (6,518 total submitted)

#3: 1972 Topps “In Action” #300 (PSA 9)

• Sold For: $4,360
• Population: Only 39 PSA 9s (1,568 total submitted)

#2: 1961 Topps #415 (PSA 9)

• Sold For: $10,300
• Population: 54 PSA 9s (4,857 total submitted)

#1: 1954 Topps Rookie Card #128 (PSA 7)

• Sold For: $15,000
• Population: 401 PSA 7s (7,538 total submitted) | Only 2 PSA 10s exist!

---

Key Takeaways from the Video:

• Population is Key: A card’s value is driven by its age and its condition rarity. Cards with few or no PSA 10s (like the 1961 Topps and the 1954 Topps rookie) command massive premiums.
• Set Builder Demand: High demand isn’t just from Aaron collectors; it’s from collectors trying to complete entire sets in high grade, pushing prices up.
• Challenging Sets: The 1971 Topps (black borders), 1955 Bowman (woodgrain borders), and 1962 Topps (woodgrain) are famously difficult to find in well-centered, high-grade condition.